The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIX, No. 5 · November 1916
84printed page
scan 12 of 26

THE MACCABAEAN

Has National Pride. Cincinnati, O., October 22, 1916. Gentlemen: Your committee of conversionists has an easy task in my case. I am not a Zionist in the sense of the Basel platform, for I do not believe in the feasibility of the autonomous commonwealth, and do not believe that even if all obstacles were overcome, such a “Judenstaat” would be a remedy for the evil from which we are suffering. I am, however, in hearty sympathy with anything tending to improve the conditions of Palestine, not merely from a sociological point of view, but from what you might call, national pride. In other words, if it becomes possible to convert all Schnorrers of Palestine into carpet weavers, and wine growers, I shall not merely rejoice at this fact because poor devils have been raised to a decent standard of life, but because it would do me good to hear of Jerusalem rugs being spoken of in the same way as Smyrna rugs, and Rishon L’Zion wine being the equal of Bordeaux, or Nir- ensteiner. Such attempts will always have mv heartiest cnınnort.

Sincerely yours,

G. DEUTSCH.

“I am not a Zionist.”

Baltimore, Md., October 11, 1916.
Dear Sirs:

Your circular letter of October 10th is before me. In reply to the same I beg to state:

1. That I am not a Zionist.

2. There exists no hope of my becoming a Zionist. My reasons are the following:

(a) I do not believe that Zionism, as a distinct movement in any one of its various phases, is compatible with the philosophy of Jewish history.

(b) I am opposed to splitting up Israel at any time into opposing parties, which an organized Zionism differentiating itself from people not affiliating with it, is calculated to bring about.

(c) I do not care to ally myself with any party in Israel having a distinct label and thus aid in abetting that division of Israel to which I just referred.

Yours sincerely,

WILLIAM ROSENAU.

A “Choveve” Zionist.

Hazleton, Pa., October 24, 1916.
Dear Colleagues:

I have the communication of the 10th from your committee before me, and in responding thereto at this time pray excuse me for not doing so before owing to holiday rush and stress of labor. I shall be brief.

I am not affiliated with the Zionist movement, not because I am a Reformed Jew, but because I am a Jew. I recognize the great awakening in Jewry produced by Zionists, who are to-day in sectionalism as many as varied as are Jews in relation to Judaism. Years ago I was a worker in the ranks of the Choveve Zion, in fact a secretary of one of the London tents (Eng.). I do not favor the establishment of a Jewish State in Palestine, yet. I am a religious

Zionist. I would work for the erection of a Jewish University and a Jewish religious centre in Jerusalem. I would do all I can, from pulpit and in press, to promote Jewish Colonies in Palestine. Politically, however, I am not a Zionist.

I have found in my wanderings and observations that a large number of the membership of local Zionist societies are socialistic, and know nothing or very little of Zionism. I must admit that there is room for much work in this direction.

With hearty greetings,

Yours fraternally and sincerely,

Is with Us.

MONTAGUE N. A. COHEN.

Avondale, Cincinnati, O., October 16, 1916.
Gentlemen:

You know, and I want to assure you again, that I am profoundly interested in Zionism and shall be glad to speak and write in its behalf.

With kind regards, believe me,

Most sincerely,

JACOB H. KAPLAN.

A Jew of the Zionist Variety.

255 West 97th Street, October 11, 1916.

Gentlemen:

I must be entirely frank in my answer to your circular as to where I stand with regard to Zionism. Your circular is addressed by Reform Rabbis to Reform Rabbis. I naturally refuse to consider myself a Reform rabbi—and my Zionism is back of this refusal. However, you did not inquire if I am a rabbi of the Reform variety, you asked to know if I am a Jew of the Zionist variety. I am saying nothing new to you in declaring that I was, am, and always will be a Zionist. My activity along Zionist lines is not very extended, comprising as it does one or two addresses a year at Zionist gatherings. None regrets this more than myself. I should be willing to associate myself with Zionist propaganda more closely; although—I must be candid—there is the barely surmountable temperamental difficulty in the way, namely, that it is well-nigh impossible for a Hungarian Jew to adjust himself to the angles of the Russo-Jewish character. However, in the interest of the cause, one would be willing to make a great many concessions. The chief difficulty, I believe, lies in the fact that the Federation has never tried to attract, with all possible seriousness and energy, all the available Zionistic forces. Possibly—and this is my impression—the official construction of the Federation as to what constitutes a Zionist is too narrow. It needs to be widened and made less technical, in order to include such as are not Shekel-sellers, or cannot for other reasons be made into more parts of a machine.

I ask, with all candor, and with no personal bias, whether an organization that neglects its own assets can ever effectively promote the cause it stands for?

Yours truly,

JOEL BLAU.

Yes, and Appeciative.

New York, N. Y., October 11, 1916.
Gentlemen:

I have received your circular letter, sent on behalf of the Federation of American Zionists. In reply I beg to say that I have been a Zionist for many years.

I fear, however, that I cannot do much to further the cause, as my work lies in other directions, my active hours being spent with prisoners and hospital patients.

I entirely agree that the Zionist movement has already done much to vitalize present-day Judaism. Its past achievements are but a harvest of greater things to come.

Yours sincerely,

HARRY L. LEWIS.

Willing to do Propaganda.

Charleston, S. C., October 16, 1916.
Dear Sirs:

In reply to your kind favor of the 10th inst., I wish to state that I have always been in thorough sympathy with the Zionist cause, and that I shall be very glad to do propaganda work in its behalf as far as my time and circumstances will permit. Any literature on the subject which you may send me will be appreciated by,

Faithfully yours,

JACOB S. RAISIN.

In Sympathy.

Paducah, Kentucky, October 17, 1916.
Gentlemen:

In reply to yours of the 10th inst., I must answer that I am not a Zionist, but that you can certainly count me in hearty sympathy with the philanthropic and humanitarian aspects of your work, and can call upon me for aid in any effort of that nature. As to the strictly cultural aspects of your activities, it can be taken for granted that any rabbi, or any person who is devoting his life to Jewish education and Jewish religion, is enlisted in the same work, though often from a different angle, and that anything partaking of the nature of Jewish education, whether in America, Palestine, or any other country, has my support. This excludes me only from your political ideal and your party organization, as I see it, but makes us co-workers in many great tasks both here and abroad.

Sincerely yours,

LEE J. LEVINGER.

Will Give Service.

New York, N. Y., October 11, 1916.
Dear Sirs:

Replying to your circular letter of the 10th, I beg to say that I shall be very glad to co-operate with you in extending your propaganda on behalf of Zionism, in any way within my power. If you care to indicate what direction my activity should take, I should be glad to receive your suggestion.

Very truly yours,

GEORGE E. KOHUT.