The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVIII, No. 5 · May 1916
112printed page
scan 16 of 26
Facsimile · scan 16 of 26
Scan of p. 112
Text · transcribed from the scan

represented as such. However, we shall pardon this oversight or perversion.

In reference to the matter of our racial organization in this country it would be interesting to learn upon what religious creed the Bnai Brith are organized. And as for the American Jewish Committee, whether they be organized on a theological basis or not, never since the days of the first Restoration was there such a confluence of power and opportunity. It is impossible to conceive of a "Babylonian Jewish Committee" impeding Ezra or Nehemiah in their work of the salvation of the nation. The Bible tells us "And whosoever remaineth in any place where he sojourneth—strengthened the hands—that did build the house of the Lord, with silver, with gold, with goods, and precious things. (Ezra 1:14.) Herzl told Baron de Hirsch significantly 'Es ist kein Wunder, wenn der (Staats mut) uns im Laufe verfolgensreicher Jahrhunderte abhanden gekommen ist.'"

It is to be hoped that, regardless of finesse of theory, some common ground for action will yet be found. Let us, veterans of history, view our problems from that perspective of history, from which personalities fade, else the Zionist hope may end in another might-have-been of history, and the world-wide emancipation of the individual Jew be followed by the general dissolution of the people, a phenonema we have unfortunately witnessed in part in the last few generations.

Some Pertinent Asides.

The attack on the Zionist leader in America is an arraignment of reform, for he is its child. It is Zionism that has brought him back to us. Like Moses of old, like Herzl of modern times, his interest in Jewish life came through non-Jewish channels. To characterize him, whose life is an embodiment of Micah's ideal, "to do justly, to love mercy and to walk humbly with God" as "shivering in spiritual nakedness" does not grace a rabbi whose own religious garments have shrunk to a fig-leaf. He is so enraptured by his own rhetoric as to forget not "to sit in the seat of scorners." Instead of assailing him for the Teshuba let this religious rabbi rather follow the advice of Maimonides in the Yad Ha-Chazakah: "If a child be captured by the Gentiles (lost to the Jews), it

is meet that he should be caused to return, and that he be influenced by words of peace until he returns (to the Torah) completely."

When Zionism is made the butt of atttack by a prominent financier we are indulgent, for as Nordau put it, "Er lebt nicht von dem Judenthum, sondern für das Judenthum."

We are indulgent because the exacting demand of his vocation, along with varied philanthropic achievements made impossible the simultaneous development of a sound theory of Jewish life. To have been born in the shadow of the anti-Messianic conference at Frankfort in 1845 is a handicap he has not been able to overcome. But despite his espousal as a “religionist,"’ his many activities are racial or national, unless we do not understand the religious significance of founding of farm colonies, diverting Jewish emigration to Galveston, or fostering the relief of Jews regardless of their theological inclinations. His practices repudiate his theories and the Jewish people are grateful therefor. But for one born in Russia of Orthodox parents, nursed al birke hatorah, we expect no less than a frank understanding of the movement which should thrill or everwhelm him. It is unfortunate that Dr. Schulman should constitute himself the opponent of those that stand for a great idealist movement that aims at perpetuating Israel in all lands of the exile as as well as in Palestine. Unless one knows Dr. Schulman’s unceasing and splendid activities in Jewish work for the past quarter century one would have to say of him, as does Graetz of the false prophets in the time of Manassah, son of Hezekiah, “What cause, however bad, if enjoying the favor of the great has not found eloquent tongues to justify it, and recommend it as the only good one?” i

Let us strive for the peace which will give strength to His people, and look forward to the prophetic time of universal peace, symbolized by Isaiah when "Ephraim will not envy Judah and Judah shall not vex Ephraim. Then will he gather the outcasts of Israel and gather together the dispersed of Judah from the four corners of the earth. . . . And the earth will be as full of the knowledge of the Lord as the waters cover the sea."