find a warrant for this divorce in facts, not in phrases, in principles, not in generalities.
The Fruits of Cosmopolitan Reform.
Early reform was an adaptation to the environment. It was postulated on the hypothesis that Jews could be Gentiles save only in creed and still remain Jews. Its aim was negative, its method destructive, and its result is extinction. Anti-Zionistic Reform is a church only in the prospective sense. Its destination is The church be it Unitarian, Christian Science, or that half-way station known as Ethical Culture. And as Nordau put it, "Wer an dieses Ziel gelangen will, der findet heute geradere und kurzere Wege dazu." The very fact that Jewish audiences or Sunday congregations tolerate such a dismemberment of Jewish life into Church and Nation is an evidence of that curtailing of Jewish education prevalent among "citizens of the Jewish persuasion." That the two most prominent reform temples have as their rabbis men born in Russia and educated under traditional influences is an evidence of the spiritual bankruptcy that followed the artificial sectioning of Jewish life that creed and race.
The Right of Cosmopolitan Reform to Parade as Religion
Assuming even the divisibility of Jewish life into religion and nation we deny the anti-Zionist his claim to religion. Will Dr. Schulman tell us specifically what does his religion consist of? How does it differ from that of the Ethical-Culturist or the Unitarian? What is there that would exclude the agnostic? The devil quoting scripture could not be more incongruous than a cosmopolitan Reform rabbi supporting his religion by quoting the Talmud, whose repudiation is of the very essence of early reform. Tovel ve-sheretz be-yoddo needs but to be revised to read Towel ve-sherets be-piv to expose the inconsistency of the Jewish church idea. To reject all that history and tradition characterized as religious and at the same time to seek identification with the separatist national religion “of the people of Israel after the Babylonian exile” is indeed a mockery. It is reminisent of Rashi's comment on Genesis 26:34 Ha-Chazir poshet telufov lomer reu sh-he-am to-hur, the swine that exhibits his cloven hoofs and says “See, I am clean!”
Are Reform and Zionism Incompatible?
In spite of the ever increasing number of adherents of Zionism in Reform pews and pulpits, Dr. Schulman tells us that "Reform Judaism and Zionism are incompatible."
Dr. David Philipson also said that once upon a time. But Dr. Max Schlessinger's powerful reply in 1907 dealt a death blow to this delusion. Paraphrasing Herzl, he said "Reform Judaism will be Zionistic, or it will not be at all." The past ten years are significant of the will-to-live in Reform circles.
For Dr. Schulman to attack non-Zionistic sympathizers of Zionism and nationalistic Reformers is indeed ungracious. The credit that is due reform Judaism lies in the fact of adjustment to life. Not one adjustment in 1805 or 1845, which is fixed with the seal of eternity by later conferences, but continual adjustment, creative evolution, if you will —in brief not Reform, but Reformation. This was and should continue to be the spirit of the movement. The late Dr. Schechter in his "Studies in Judaism" shows that the "general customs of the time forms the real rule of practice."
With a philosophy that is out of date, the rabbis of anti-Zionistic Reform pathetically cling to a shadow of their own making. With a "consistency, worthy of small minds," they hark back to a doctrine which the social sciences have undermined, and which the subsequent devel-
opment of nationalism in the nineteenth century has demonstrated to be false. Conservative Reform Zionists as well as the notyet-Zionists are the living heirs of Leopold Zunz and Zacharias Frankel and the “positive historic school.” The whole group of radical anti-Zionists are hoist on their own petard.
Democracy and the Hyphen.
If Israel of to-day as a distinct social group, outside of Palestine, in the various lands of the exile is to make any further contribution to human progress it is to be the mission, not of the individual Jew struggling for freedom, for individual non-conformity has many another champion. The creative and oppressed soul of the Jewish people is to teach the lesson, not merely of group toleration, idealized in an uninteresting Chinesism, but of group expression in America's great democracy. Here is a task taxing as much Zionist potentialities to produce new values, as Israel’s fortitude to live and transmit them, and calling for the exercise of the highest ideals of our republic, pioneer of human society on the frontiers of a new freedom.
In using the much abused term “hyphen” Dr. Schulman is allowing himself to become the dupe of mere words without investigating their content. The execrable charge originating among and uttered by Jews alone that Zionism and patriotim were incompatible was exposed as a miserable fiction, not by words, but by the blood of English Zionists at Ladysmith. On every battlefield in the present war Zionists are disproving with their lives the hyphen slander; be it in Turkey, where Zionism and patriotism are synonymous, or in France where devotion to Israel is wedded to loyalty to the land of adoption. The bugaboo of the hyphen is the resurrected ghost of the earlier chauvinistic charge. It is a single track loyalty originatinge in a single track mind.
Lafayette, Steuben, and Pulaski were no less loyal to their respective countries because of their sympathies for the fathers of our republic. I can see in my mind's eye some assimilated and long forgotten rabbi of the first Restoration, may be a “Babylonian subject of the Jewish persuasion,” dubbing Nehemiah, cup-bearer to the King, a hyphenated Babylonian. I can picture, though with difheulty, some mediaeval expounder of the “theory of the Jewish church,” or rather of the “Jewish mosque” branding Chasdai Ibn Shaprut, the minister to the Caliph, a hyphenated Spaniard. We do not think of those Americans like John Wanamaker or Willem Hendrick Van T.oon, who support the claims of Belgium and Poland to a renewal of their nationality as hyphenated, nor do we regard those Americans of French or English descent who unobstrusively favor the Allies’ cause as less loyal to America. It is only the treasonable activity of bomb throwers, firebrands, and spies that has cast odium on a section of our citizenry. And when this war shall cease, we may welcome, again, the maintenance of German traditions in America, as we have encouraged, during the war itself, the development of a French culture in the form of the drama.
The reverend lecturer identifies Zionism with the “mad nationalism that is devastating Europe.” If after viewing the league, nationally incongruous, of Teuton and Turk on the one side, and Saxon and Serb on the other, he still persuades himself that nationalism brought on the war he might with advantage read the scientific presentation of the conflict by Prof. E. R. A. Seligman in an “Economic Interpretation of the War.”
We wish to remind Dr. Schulman that the Congress resolution mentions nothing about Jewish national rights in America. The clause in question refers plainly and unmistakingly to those countries. where :nationalities are
