The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVIII, No. 2 · February 1916
37printed page
scan 15 of 28
37

Zionism as An Ideal

THE remarkable phenomenon of our people retaining its individuality without a fatherland and through centuries of cruel persecution is ascribed by some to religious, by others to ethnological or to politico-economical causes. But religion is no longer universally considered the most potent factor in human affairs and history, and the Jewish riddle can hardly be solved by ethnological or economical factors alone. The destiny of a people is shaped neither by religious nor entirely by external circumstances, but chiefly by its national character and by its aspirations towards definite aims.

What are the cardinal traits of our national character, and what were and are our aspirations? What is it that made us sustain long centuries of inhuman persecution? What impelled the Jew to offer himself a voluntary martyr? I shall attempt to answer these questions.

Titus conquered Judea, but did not conquer Judaism. The Jew lost his soul, but retained his soul. He was expelled from his country, but could not be made to expell it from his memory. If he could not return to Zion he brought Zion to himself. No matter wherever the Jew lived the voice of his prophets still rang in his ears. If the creative power of the Jewish genius was paralysed for the time being, his past had sufficient power to feed his soul and to preserve it from destruction. Not only did the sacred memories of his past compensate him for his tribulations, but promised him a great future. As soon as the material, the physical campaign was over he began a new campaign, a spiritual one, for the preservation of his nationality. This became his sole aim; an aim on which he concentrated all his efforts. The colleges he founded in Jabneh, Tiberias, Nahardoah and other Babylonian centres were all directed towards the attainment of this aim. He strained all his energy in a struggle not so much for a national life as against national death. Neither his gentle friends nor his enemies could understand this struggle. Why did not the Jew allow his soul to be melted in the melting-pot of Roman culture? And whence did he derive the indomitable courage in his terrible fight against national extinction?

The Jew, in the early period of his exile continued his national life in spite of all obstacles and hardships, because he had a great past behind and foresaw a great future before him. It was he who discovered and proclaimed to the world the idea of monotheism and the elements of social justice. These eternal revelations made their author immortal. His prophets —the prophets of truth and righteousness—still spoke to him from the hills of his dear homeland. Bodily he was now a slave, subdued and down-trodden, but spiritually he was still the free Judean. Everything was still fresh in his memory: the flourishing towns and vilages, the lofty mountains, the beautiful valleys and blossoming gardens and vineyards, the stately cedar-forests, the thousands of pilgrims streaming to Jerusalem and the Temple in its full glory. .. What did it matter that these were temporarily lost, if they were alive in his soul. The eternal values he created there would survive all future generations, would

triumph in the end over all ephemeral strength and grandeur of a world based on fire and sword. . . For did not his prophets tell him to wait for the day, when he would regain all his past glory in his ancestral home? Or did he doubt their word? “Live and wait” became the motto of his life. What signified temporary suffering when compared with his unshaken belief in regaining his national freedom? Faith, illimitable faith in his future independence was the basis of his existence. It dominated all his thoughts, characterized all his actions; it pervaded his whole literature, his philosophical doctrines, his liturgy, his poetry, his social, political, moral and aesthetic views. If the existing conditions were hard he sought ways and means of adapting himself to them. How was it that a simple agricultural people was suddenly transformed into a people of crafty tradesmen? Was it really due, as Sombart asserts, to the Jew’s innate desire for wealth? Oh, no! history testifies that the Jew often paid for his faith with all his material possessions, even with his life when occasion demanded—and occasion demanded it too often. It was purely a question of adaptation to existing circumstances. He was outwardly a cosmopolitan, but inwardly a citizen of Jerusalem. He lived among all nationalities, but belonged to none; he adapted himself to all external circumstances, but would adapt himself to no spiritual conditions, The present time was of no consequence to him: he lived in his real past and his visionary future. He did not even endeavor to create new national values. How could he hope to reveal new truths, how could he “sing the song of the Lord on strange soil?” This would be done “When the redeemed of the Lord would return and come with singing into Zion.” Besides, the Jewish character permits of no compromises. The Jew is extreme in his nature: he is either absolutely conservative or absolutely radical; he either erects shrines or destroys them; he will either give to the world the Book of Books, sing the Song of Songs or remain silent altogether. He must have either all or nothing. His national soul, unbent and untarnished, must be preserved for the future—his full and complete redemption, when his national genius would reassert itself in its entirely. This was his Messianic faith. His Messiah could not compromise. This is probably why the Jews did not recognize Jesus who adapted his teachings to the conditions of his time, conditions largely controlled by Rome. Christian theologians never fully realized this. The true Messianic idea was not something nebulous, vague or abstract, as some twentieth century Rabbis try to make out. It was plain, clear and definite: Messiah is to take the people of Israel back to the land of Israel, the land which is the physical and spiritual cradle of the Jewish people, the arena from which the highest eternal truths were proclaimed, and whence, when re-gathered. he will proclaim new truths to the entire world. The Messianic ideal was the raison d’etre of the Jew in exile, it was the motive force of all metamorphoses and vieissitudes through which the Jewish people passed. It so filled the Jewish soul that hardly any space was left in it for other ideals. The Jewish mind was made up. Allor nothing. Messiah or exile!