Interpretations of a Cartoon
WE give elsewhere several letters received from esteemed Zionists who protest against the use of the cartoon which appeared in the January issue of The Maccabaean. These letters were selected from a number of communications and resolutions practically repeating the same objections. It is presumed, therefore, that they reflect a large body of Zionist opinion, which, in a democratic movement like ours, is entitled to a respectful and considerate hearing.
It may seem a trivial matter to discuss an illustration in a magazine; there are all sorts of tastes in this world, and what one may regard as a bad drawing another may say is good, and what one may regard as vulgar another may claim to be merely virility; but the nature of the criticism of the January cartoon raises issues of a broader import, which should be openly discussed. As a rule, all cartoons, good or bad, tackle situations with graphic boldness. This inevitable boldness seems to have affected a number of Zionists unpleasantly. They probably would not have been so affected by they were used to the consideration of Jewish controversial questions as such questions are treated in American or English political life.
Many Zionists assume that the opposition to Zionism is based on ignorance of the facts or wilfulness, and that our propaganda should consist mainly in explaining our objects, telling the story of our achievements in Palestine, and collecting funds for the work in Palestine. It is thought that this propaganda, suavely conducted, and politely expounded, will win over our active opponents. Such an idea implies a naive understanding of our problem.
The opposition is not mere whim and ignorance. It is deliberate and conscious of its purpose. It is based upon a different interest in life, the interests of a nationally de- classe element, which is determined that no Jewish national objective shall interfere with their denationalized way of living. This opposition feels that Zionism has come to disturb the status quo of American Jewry, introducing new ideals and new methods. It claims that Zionism is in contradiction to both American patriotism and to the conception of Jewish life which reduces the ties that bind to a religious bond. We may think that logically there is no such contradiction. We may declare there is no such contradiction. But they feel keenly that there is such a contradiction. When the various gentlemen who have been attacking Zionism publicly write and speak against Zionism, they do so because they feel that we have come to destroy their conception of Judaism, that we have come to offer national resistance to the forces of assimilation, that we aim to establish a Jewish nationality recognized by the world, and that we bringe an ideal that requires consecreation to new tasks.
The Zionist ideal is not pleasing to our active opponents, for it is an undesired intrusion into the scheme of Jewish life which they have framed for us. It interferes with their lives, with their interests, with their religion. This opposition is not due to ignorance, but to knowledge that what we intend doing is vitally offensive. They understand our arguments, and do not accept them as valid. They do not want to acknowledge their validity, for our views contradict every thing they have been saying and writing and living for the past forty years. They exalt the golus which we denounce and condemn.
You cannot combat this antagonism by slipping a brochure into the pocket of a prominent rabbi, or arguing with him in the Jewish press. That antagonism cannot be reduced effectively only by parlor meetings, which are good in their way. It must be met by public discussion on the lines of national controversy and struggle. In national life, we deal with actions not words. When we find ourselves confronted by a crisis in national existence, with a world-wide catastrophe requiring relief, Jews who stand up at public meetings and denounce us for doing what we think is right and inevitably necessary are not merely persons who happen to differ with us in opinion. They are opponents of the national interest; and they must be so considered.
Do we not regard ourselves as a nationality? Is not our problem a national problem? We do so assert. Then the etiquete of a tea-party cannot be invoked to guide our conduct. A new set of rules must be employed, the rules of controversy that apply to national issues. We regret
to note that among Zionists there are many who are not accustomed to thinking of Jewish life in national terms, which demands for its own health that its affairs be conducted in the open, with an undeviating policy behind it.
When the Italian people are involved in political issues, the Italian press and all Italian publicists discuss them boldly and frankly, disregarding the dignity or interests of individuals. The discussion may be brutal and frank, but the national interest over-rides the interests of individuals, and the amenities of private social intercourse.
Zionism has been too long regarded as a domestic affair, regulated by the etiquette of the home or the synagogue or the board meeting. We are arousing, however, the national consciousness and we must expect in that development the birth of the usual methods employed in the discussion and propaganda of national issues. If in this work it becomes necessary to characterize, graphically or otherwise, the public actions of men or organizations, heretofore operating as private individuals or corporations, although dealing with public Jewish matters, surely Zionists should be the last to resent the use of such methods. Zionism must get out into the street to reach the Jewish people. It cannot succeed as a Chautauqua summer assembly.
If in discussing the Congress movement, The Maccabaean has criticized a certain type or set of men, it has done so in matters affecting Jewish national interests, and with no personal motive or intent. The actions of this organization were detrimental to the national interests of the Jewish people. We were concerned with the public aspects of the situation. The organization in question stands opposed to democracy (without which Zionism becomes a philanthropic movement solely); in opposition to nationality (without which Zionism has no meaning); and in opposition to Zionist influence in American Jewish affairs (without which Zionism becomes, like a fungus, without roots in real life, hanging in the air of sentimental longing or theoretical discussion). In combating this position, we discussed the issues freely and frankly, seeking to show that the upholders of that position lacked authority for speaking in the name of people whom they did not represent, seeking to show that the men had not given serious thought to those Jewish affairs on which they expected to be regarded as authorities, seeking to invalidate the authority of the men who thus spoke publicly as Jewish representatives, inasmuch as they did not speak the right word, and wished to oppress American Jewry with the weight of their hitherto unchallenged authority. Those who think of Zionism as a movement that must gain by compromising in its methods with individual opinions and individual whims are weakening Zionism and reducing it to a feeble and ineffective expression of a noble ideal. Zionism must transform Jewish character, and make the Jew thinking of Jewish life in terms of individual interests, a man thinking of Jewish life as a national organism, into which all individual ambitions and possessions must be merged.
The American Jewish Committee, for example, opposed the self-emancipation of the Jewish people. It used means and methods that indicated that the question was serious to its welfare. In opposing it with the weapons of public discussion, we felt and still feel that we were opposing the commission of a great wrong to the Jewish nationality. If in opposing the perpetration of such a wrong, we seemed to be rude and vulgar in the eyes of Zionists, and not considerate enough to the high standing of many of the men opposed, we simply express our sorrow and regret that Zionists should think that we have committed a wrong worthy of censure.
As to the cartoon itself, we confess that the figure of the leading opponent was not pleasing to us either. But the artist had a method of his own, and thought that in this way he struck at the root of the situation. His aim was not to deride the appearance of any particular opponent, but merely to give point to the Jewish aspects of the controversy. We are at a loss to understand why we should be charged with anti-Semitism. There was no desire to mock at Jewish characteristics, which to us are matters of pride and not of shame. Those Jewish features which unfriendly cartoonists employ to give point to their dislike of Jews, are features which to us seem natural, desirable and even agreeable.