ish political influence was to be used in behalf of Turkey. Herzl's character alone would be proof enough of its untruth. But the actual political conditions disprove it, and it is pretty certainly known that the compact was to be on a purely financial basis, and that the reason Herzl failed was because he could not get the co-operation of the Jewish financiers.
Zionism is a democratic, a folk movement. Among all democratic, individualistic people there are factions and divisions. The opposition to Zionism is a minority even though the organized Zionists are also a minority. The great bulk of the Jews are consciously or unconsciously in sympathy with us. As for the parties in Zionism, they are not in opposition to one another, but are accentuating different aspects of Jewish life and working together for the same ends. Even the Territorialists will return to us when we can prove to them that Palestine is "practical."
2 re Fe ch ke ee Shesthien. Deta hu What different things we may, mean when we speak of Jewish genius! One may speak of the genius of the Jewish people, and of the genius of individual Jews. In all the countries of the world there have been Jews who have made good in the various arts and sciences, although the very highest expression was denied them because the highest expression, at least in art, is always intensely national. But the genius of the Jewish people has not expressed itself except in Jewish nationalist form. The writers of the exile in Babylon and Jehuda Halevi, the two chief examples of Jewish genius outside of Palestine, while they did not do their work in Palestine, they did it in relation you can give to the Jews a national inspiration and still take away from them the desire for national life isan enigma which I], for one, cannot solve. The Jews in Palestine never were segregated and never will be segregated. There will be just as many Jews in most countries after we have our national center as there have been or would be without it. But those Jews will have a continuous source of inspiration from the national life in the national home.
I deny that Zionism breeds prejudice between Jews and Gentiles. Personally, I have found more content and more inspiration in my relation with Christians since I am a Zionist that I did before. If prejudice is judging the individual before knowing him, what of judging the individual before knowing him, what of judging groups before knowing them? How can the individual Jew justify himself if he accepts adulation from Christians who are prejudiced against the Jewish people? No greater insult can be offered to the Jew than to be told that he is different from other Jews, therefore acceptable. There is surely no harm in a pride which refuses to be comforted at the expense of a people.
As for the Jew living in co-operation with the Gentile, that is what all Zionists wish and what they do. They know that loyalty to the past, that to be true to the ultimate Jewish ideal within them, makes them worthier men, worthier Americans. America is not losing the idealism "wasted" on Zionism. It is enriched by it, it is kindled by it, as a flame kindles other flames, "so nobleness enkindleth nobleness."
We American Zionists feel that our experience in America will help ustoa fuller understanding of political ideas for Palestine and that our Jewish culture and nurture must enrich America, that they are the only
things which we have to give which can enrich America.
According to the platform of the Ethical Culture Society, there is absolutely no reason why its members should be opposed to Zionism. The Zionists as well as they wish to work in relation with our Gentile neighbors and for the common good of humanity. They also are dedicated to the ever-increasing knowledge, practice and love of the right. They believe that this is Jewish. Ethical Culture has then nothing that is not a natural outgrowth of the development of the Jewish ideal. So Christianity, as expressed by Jesus, contained nothing which was not contained in the personal morality of the Jewish writers of his time. Paul, the Jew, apostle to the Gentiles, added much and dropped much in order to fit Jewish doctrine to the needs of a strange people. It seems to us as if Professor Adler were doing the same, as if he were an apostle carrying a Jewish message to the Gentiles. He is fitting it to their need. He attracts the assimilating Jew and the Gentile. In the future, there will be no Jews in the Ethical Culture Society.
“ I believe that under Professor Adler’s avowed purpose, as under our avowed purpose, lies as deep as sub-conscious and all-powerful purpose as moves us. Under our avowed purpose of rebuilding the Jewish land, Palestine, and re-establishing there the Jewish people, lies the deep, sub-conscious purpose of fulfilling a national ideal in the world and for the world. Under his avowed purpose of serving the right lies the deep and sub-conscious purpose of assimilating with other peoples and other ideals. Whatever Professor Adler himself may believe, I am convinced that to the majority of the members of the Ethical Culture Society, Ethical Culture is a respectable, “moral” way of escaping from the difficult obligation of being a Jew. Professor Adler said that he resented our position because we dared to claim that Jews were not doing their duty if they were not Zionists. We do make that claim, and we base iton a fundamental ethical concept. We consider loyalty to be the underlying human virtue, The many members of the “Ethical” congregation, believe that Ethical Culture is like the charity of a man who has done a great wrong. It is the desire to whitewash with all other possible virtues the glaring gap that ar ven left by forgetting this fundamental virtue of ovaltv.
If what I say is not true, then I cannot understand why Professor Adler or the members of his Society should repudiate the ideal of Zionism. There is no antagonism on the surface between their platform and ours. There is no antagonism in the depth of our hearts. If there is antagonism on their part, I can conceive of its coming only from the deep-rooted desire to assimilate.
Professor Adler ended by speaking of the morning glow on the Rockies and the evening glow on Mt. Hermon. It was a pretty figure, but I cannot see that it had any pertinence or that the facts point to its realization. A people is immortal as an individual is immortal, through vision, service and sacrifice. If the Jewish people can gain for itself this kind of immortality, and make the world continuously its debtor, what right has any Jew, in the face of such an ideal, to say the fureral oration over us in the midst of our return to spiritual youth ?
