ing the truth of the Zionist ideal, but it was not because of their desire to escape Anti-Semitism that they became Zionists. As Schmarya Levin has said, Anti-Semitism was the button that turned on the light, but unless there had been electricity, there could have been no light.
The effect of Anti-Semitism on Zionism is interesting in the light it throws on recent history. The Jew had made the effort to assimilate, in Russia through the Haskallah movement, in Germany through the indirect influence of Mendelsohn and the Reform movement. He was met by persecution in Russia, by Anti-Semitism in Germany and France. He then realized that he could not find his salvation or his personal dignity in the respect paid to him by other persons, but that first of all he must respect himself for that which he actually is. Anti-Semitism was the slap in the face which a king may give to his cringing vassal, and the slap made the Jew realize that his place was not that of a cringing vassal.
Zionists do not try to escape from Anti-Semitism in its form of social persecution. They ignore it. They scarcely feel it as individual because their life is too full of its own content to be troubled by the social prejudice of others. Zionists can meet Christians on a much fairer plane than can the assimilating Jew; they find less prejudice, and more mutual interest. The martyrdom of the Jew in his acceptance of social prejudice may call forth praise, but I confess that it seems childish to me. What have we, the martyrs who have faced death and worse than death for centuries without flinching, to do with this petty martyrdom of the summer hotel and college club? When we Zionists wish to convince some assimilated Jew of the truth of Zionism, we tell him what we believe to be true —that Zionism will probably help in varioius ways to do away with social prejudice. This interests him. It does not specially interest us.
With our ideal of nationalism, there can be no conflict between different nationalisms within a state. The patriotism of the Irish Home Rulers in America has never been doubted. As for my Americanism, whatever deepens my humanity, deepens my Americanism, and my Zionism deepens my humanity.
It is an accepted fact that the Pilgrim Fathers founded America on Old Testament ideas. That America is to work out certain things which are not contained in the Bible is just as true as that the Jews, even in America, are to work out certain things for the world which are not contained in the Bible The Jew does not live by books alone. He lives by the full blooded experience of the Jewish people, interpreting in its life the traditions, the ideals and the aspirations that by its life it has embodied in its books.
Dr. Adler believes that because he has studied Jewish history, the Bible and Hebrew literature, he understands the inwardness of Jewish life. I venture to say that the little East side boy or girl of whom he spoke, and who is tranfıgured by the ideals of Zionism, may respond to the inwardness of that life better than he. There were many Jews in the Middle ages learned in the Talmud and Bible who forsook their people, who became Catholic priests and even turned against their people. Therefore it is not necessarily true that Jewish learning gives us an insight into the ideals of the Tewish people.
Would Zionism prevent Russian persecution? Had we fulfilled the ideal of Zionism long ago, Russian
persecution would probably have been impossible. We are not attempting to meet one problem, but all the problems of the Jews at once. Zionism is not merely a geographic movement. It involves the organization of the whole Jewish people. At present, the Jewish people is a mass of individuals that can be outraged as their oppressors please, with no means even of protesting, except indirectly through other nations. If the thirteen million Jews in the world were organized, and if somewhere they had the life-giving center which would make that organization possible, they would be a body capable of acting for themselves continuously. As Mr. Brandeis has said, the reason the Jews in Poland are so much worse off than the Belgians is that the Jews, having no organization, have no basis for credit. They cannot be dealt with as a unit. In fact they cannot be dealt with at all.
Palestine is about the same size as Belgium or Holland and could hold six or seven million people. But all that is not really to the point. When we say that Zionism will solve the Jewish problem, we do not believe that it will make all the Jews of the world happy immediately. We mean that it will solve the unnatural position of the people, that it will solve the spiritual problem for those Jews who long to live a complete Jewish life, to fulfill the inward Jewish promise, and who see no place save our own Jewish land where this can be done.
Are we too impatient to solve our problem, when there are so many other problems to be solved? We are no more impatient than the others. In fact, we are the others, for the social problem is also our problem. Since our ideal is justice for the small nation, justice and democracy among nations, we could not work for our ideal without working for the ideal of social justice. We are working for what we desire and for what we consider right. We do not expect to get what we desire without great sacrifice in the future as we have made great sacrifice in the past. If I knew to-day that we could not return to our national home for the next two thousand years, and that during those two thousand years it would be as terrible a struggle as in the past to maintain what I consider a sacred trust, I would continue to do exactly what I am doing at this moment.
In working for our right, we are working for the right of all oppressed peoples. That is the task of the Jew—to make the world see the individuality and responsibility of nations, to teach them that the national unit is something more and different than the sum of individuals who compose the nation. Shall we not give to the world in the future national law and national righteousness, as we gave to the world in the past individual righteousness? This is the ideal which underlies the labors and hopes of every Zionist.
Why should we not sue the nations for help? We are willing to be materially dependent and interdependent with all the nations. Would it be better to fight than to sue? There are today only seven hundred thousand people in Palestine. There is no reason why they should oppose us when we go there with a proper understanding. It is true that that understanding is not yet established.
I question the ethics of Professor Adler's mentioning the base and groundless slander of bargain between Herzl and the Sultan in regard to the Armenian massacres, whereby, as a reward for concessions, Jew-
