traditions, due to our entire life through all civilization of which religion forms a vital but not the entire part. We feel bound together because we are Jews although our creeds are as wide apart as the most radical member of Sinai stands religiously distant from the most orthodox Jew of Jerusalem. There is a tie that binds us in some common elements in that religious faith. There is a tie that binds us, however, over and beyond that religious faith, the tie of belonging together through all the ages, a tie that we do not want to loosen and that if we did want to loosen we could not because the law of nations forbids us.
Now then, what does Zionism aim at? A Homeland for the Jewish nation, a homeland in the only place that the Jewish nation can ever hope or dream of having a real homeland, in the land towards which our fathers have ever looked in the last nineteen centuries, in the old homeland of the Jewish nation, in Palestine.
It may be all a dream. Practical politics and the clashing of material and economic interests may prevent its realization; but it is a dream that has made Jews Jews again, in greater numbers than any other thought, than any other belief that has ever come to the Jews of the world.
Now, I need not tell you, my friends, how absurd it is when the anti-Zionists say; well then, you can't be a real good American or a real good German or a real good Englishman because you really think you are a citizen of this future state in Palestine. Well, in the first place, if the Jewish people ever get the homeland in Palestine it would not be a homeland for the fourteen million Jews now living, or their children. It may be a homeland for three, four, five million of them, possibly more, but no Jew anywhere is going to be compelled to be a citizen of the new Jewish state; no American Jew is going to be deprived of his American citizenship involuntarily. But the American Jew, if the state ever comes, will have the same freedom that every American citizen now has, to go to the Jewish state if he wants to go to the Jewish state, just as the German in America or the Englishman in America can go back to Germany, can go back to England if he wants to go back. And the Jew in America although he feels himself a part of the Jewish people through the world, although he wants to see the Jewish nation as such re-established in its homeland, although he wants to see a Jewish state ranking with the other states of the world, the protector of the Jew in the countries where the Jew is oppressed, need not for a moment either want to become or actually become a citizen of that state himself. In my judgment, if the Jewish state were realized at this moment, the great mass of American Jews would remain in America as American citizens and just as patriotic American citizens as the people of any other nation and any other country who have come to America to form a part of this Federation of all the nations of the world.
Now, what is our next duty, after answering the non-Zionists and the anti-Zionists and after defending what ought never to nced a defense, our American citizenship, our American nationality? Mind you, I do not boast of my American patriotism. I am an American. It is a matter of course. I only speak as I do now in answer to the charge that is so often made against us, and in the hope that perhaps I might have helped you or some of you who meet - the charge to give some answer to it. But we have other duties, much more important than this. I say much more important; at least equally important, because I regard the answering of the non-Jew of importance, not merely to refute the charge, but to covince a fellow Jew that he ought to be with us, and that having seen the error of his ways, having been convinced that this thought of incompatability and mutual exclusion of Americanism and Judaism is false, he would not hang back in his duty to his fellow Jews but that he still will fulfill that duty in, what seems to me not, perhaps, the only way but the best way, by joining the ranks of the Zionists, by aiding the Zionists to help along the realization of these dreams and, until the dream itself is realized, to help along those of our fellow Jews throughout the world that want to build the nucleus of that future state in the colonization of Palestine.
I shall not speak of the immediate situation produced by the war, except to say that because of the war those colonies are in most imminent and terrible danger. If the aim of Zionism is ever to be realized, whether in our time or our children or grand children's time, we must not let the work of the past thirty-five years die out and be forgotten. Palestine has over a hundred thousand Jews. As you know, the vast majority of the pious Jews have gone there to die in the Holy Land. That has been the custom of pious Jews for centuries. But during the past thirty-three years a new generation has gone to and been born in Palestine. Men and women go there now, not to die but to live, go there
to live the Jewish life that they want to live, go there now to attain a freedom which they cannot attain anywhere else in the world because even in our own countrv. tıouglı freedoın is given to everyone, so far as the law can give it, real freedom is not given to a great many, so far as the economic despotism that neccessarily controls their lives is concerned. You know, too, many of you orthodox Jews know, that you cannot maintain yourselves in this country as you would like to maintain yourselves and yct live the Jewish life as you feel it your duty, or as your parents, I wıll say, felt it their duty to live it and as they would like to see their children live it. And I say that as one frankly who so far as religious conceptions and creeds are concerned is himself a radical Jew and not an orthodox Jew, one who for himself does not fecl the binding forces of the law as many of you feel it, but I have the decpest sympathy with the man who feels the force of that law as his religious duty, who aims to live up to all that he believes should be the right way of living, and who, because of the actual conditions of life is unable to live the real life that he wants to live. And I say that for these people real freedom in every sense of the word is had only in the colonies of Palestine, where a Jew, where the most orthodox Jew can be a Jew, a man living the life exactlv as he wants to live it.
Now, I do not complain, either for myself or for my orthodox friend of the possibility of life in America. I believe that no where under the sun, except in those colonies, is the possibility of realizing their aim as great as in our country. And I hope for the sake of the millions of Jews living in oppressed lands that the possibilities of coming to America will never be denied to them, and I hope it ever more for America’s sake for what these Jews have brought into the American melting pot, for what of idealism these Jews of oppressed countries ever will bring into the American life. And we brought it not only directly; we brought it indirectly. The Old Testament and its ideals of democracy and social justice were the conceptions that ruled the carly New Englanders and the Old Testament ideals are bound up with the life and the development of American civilization. If the Jews have their own homeland there is every reason to believe that those same conceptions of democracy and social justice will prevail and will be developed there, and that that country in its development of social life will be an example for all countries of the world. It is up to us here in America, free from the disasters of this great world war, we, the only Jews in the world who know to-day what freedom means, what opportunities liberty gives, we who are prosperous beyond all the dreams of our ancestors, we who are prosperous beyond all the Jews in these countries where the battles are going on, it is up to us to realize our duty to our fellow Jews. There are many duties. There are the duties toward the Jewish families stricken in this war beyond all others because they are Jews. The poor Jews in Poland and Galicia, I am not speaking to-night of our duty there. Within a short time we will hold a meeting to endeavor to arouse every Jew in America to the fulfillment of his duty toward the war sufferers. But it is our duty at this time when all the world seems in chaos, when Jew is fighting fellow Jew in pursuance of his duty toward his native country, it is up to us to do what we can to preserve that nucleus of the future Jewish nation. It is up to us to see to it that these colonies in Palestine are permitted to grow, are permitted to live and are given the means of living; that our institutions founded in the last thirty years, primarily, although not exclusively by the Zionists, are maintained. We can only do this through organization, through complete national organization in America. We can only do this by enlisting the active sympathy of every American ceitizen. Without organization our forces would be scattered, our energies would be lessened, our ability to give will be diminished. With organization, pulling together, with a single aim, knowing what we want, knowing that we can realize if we will but do our duty, realize at least in a measure what we are aiming at, we can overcome all obstacle, we can save the colonies of Palestine, but we cannot do without organization. We cannot do it without getting and enlisting every man and women in the ranks of the Zionists, because it is up to the Zionists. It is up to the world organization of Zionist to save what they have started, to help what they have begun. Here in this center of the country you, the Knights of Zion, represent the Ziohists of the world. This is their convention. This is their knight. I belong to them. You, young men, all of you, join their ranks, list yourselves under their banner, fight for your traditions, your ancestry, your beliefs. You will thus remain true Americans and vou will be true Tews.
