The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVIII, No. 1 · January 1916
15scan
of 32
Facsimile · scan 15 of 32
Scan of scan 15
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Mass Meeting of the Knights of Zion Convention

The principal mass-meeting of the convention of the Knights of Zion was held on Sunday evening, January 2nd, at the Chicago Hebrew Institute. The hall was overcrowded, and an overflowing meeting was held in the Assembly Hall of the Institute. In the main hall, Nathan D. Kaplan was the chairman, and the speakers were Hon. Julian W. Mack, Mr. Louis D. Brandeis and Dr. Schmarya Levin. In the assembly hall, Leon Zolotkoff was the chairman, with the same speakers, augmented by Max Shulman and Dr. Yudelson.

In opening the meeting in the main hall, Mr. Kaplan said: Nineteen years ago a convention was held in the City of Chicago, consisting of representatives of a few local organizations which had sprung into existence for the purpose of furthering the thoughts of bringing about to a practical realization the two thousand year dream of the restoration of a Jewish Homeland in Palestine. This convention organized itself and adopted the name of Knights of Zion. Subsequently there was organized the American Federation of Zionists. And with the organization of that body the Knights of Zion fixed its jurisdiction over the ten middle-western States.

“In these nineteen years that organization has held conventions annually and has persistently propagated the principles of Zionism, with a determined perseverance bent only upon ceasing when the entire Jewish people shall have recognized Zionism as the solution of the Jewish world problem. During these nineteen years the Zionist movement has spread and grown. During this period the workers in the organization were limited to those only who entertained within themselves the conviction that they are the descendants of a people, which, once having contributed something to the progress of the civilization of the world, can, if permitted to again, assume its historic thread where it was left cut off two thousand years ago, participate in the development of the world’s civilization and again contribute something to the world without which the world is the poorer.

“The difficulty, the greatest difficulty has been in convincing our own people of the logic of this program; but with the development of events, year by year, the forces grew, and as the forces grew the sentiment for a better knowledge of Zionism spread among the peoples of the world until to-day, with the tragic conditions that are presented to us by reason of the struggle that is going on abroad, finds the entire Jewish people of this country struggling with the problem of how best to solve the Jewish question, and some of the greatest thinkers have dared to step out and say “We see the light of the argument of Zionism. We find that the Zionists who have modestly, humbly, but persistently hammered for the realization of their ideal, that which we thought was an impractical dream, have offered that which really is the solution of the Jewish problem.” These great men have stepped to the front of the Zionist movement. And of these great men it is our especial distinction and privilege to have two of the greatest with us this evening. It is going to be our pleasure and privilege and benefit to listen to these gentlemen, and because of the fact that one of these gentlemen is one of our own in this great City of Chicago and in this great middle-western territory, because of the fact that he has come out as a Zionist when he was convinced after years of study, the like of which few of the people, of the Jewish people have given to the cause and the suffering and the conditions of our people, after years of careful study and devotion to the interests of our people, after studying all the problems, philanthropic, social, economic and otherwise of our people, has come out and declared himself a Zionist and has taken the lead as one of the leaders of the Zionist movement in this country, because he is one of our own I take the pleasure and privilege of introducing as the first speaker of this evening Julian W. Mack, Judge of the United States Court.”

JUDGE MACK: Friends, I must disclaim much that the presiding officer has just said. I am not a leader in the Zionist rank; I am but a humble follower. I have studied comparatively little. There is very, very much for me to learn about Zionism and about Jews. But I am convinced, so far as I have been enabled to think about the problem of the Jew, that the aim of the Zionists is right. Whether Zionism will solve the world-wide Jewish problem or not is an entirely different matter. Even if the highest and broadest aims of the Zionists be realized, I fear there will

still be a Jewish problem all over the world; but surely that problem will be a different one from the problem that now confronts the Jew everywhere, even in this great land.

I did not know just what kind of an audience I was to address to-night. I rather thought a large percentage would be composed of Zionists and to some extent of anti-Zionists. And while I had framed no address I did think that I should try to say something to convince them that there was at least something in Zionism that ought to hold their attention and engage their hearts as well as their head. But when I look in your faces I feel very humbly that I ought to sit down and have you talk to me because surely 95 per cent. of you are Zionists, and you need no word of mine to convince you of what Zionism is, and what Zionism means. And yet perhaps even those of you who are in full sympathy with the end and aim of Zionism, those of you who yourselves have prayed and whose ancestors never failed to pray for their return to Jerusalem, may not be fully alive to the duty that confronts Zionists in this country.

The first duty, it seems to me, of every Zionist is to meet the charge that is so often made against us, that Zionism and Americanism are mutually exclusive, the charge made by the anti-Zionists that a Zionist cannot be a true American citizen. If that were true I could not stand before you as a Zionist, for I claim to be, as all of you who have been born here or who have been naturalized here will claim with me, to be as good American citizens as those whose ancestors or who themselves were English or German or French or of any other nationality. And the confusion that underlies this charge, the confusion introduced, sometimes purposely, more often ignorantly, is the result of not distinguishing between one’s nationality and one’s political allegiance, between a nation and a state; and that is due to the fact that the word “nation” is used in many different significations. When I say that I belong to the Jewish nation, that I am of Jewish nationality, I don’t say that I don’t belong to the American nation, because a man can have, in my judgment and in my sense of the word, more than one nationality; but he can have only one citizenship, only one political allegiance. He can be a member of only one state. And those of us who are American citizens belong by political allegiance to this country as citizens of this country in every sense of the word.

Moreover, there is in this country not merely a political allegiance to the state; there is a bond that unites all of the people in one growing nation, a nation different from most of the nations of the world, a nation still in the making, a nation in which, perhaps, one element is predominant, but not so predominant as it is in most of the countries of Europe. The Anglo-Saxon nationality is the nationality of, perhaps, a majority of the people of this country. In any event, more American citizens are of Anglo-Saxon nationality than of any other nationality. But this country has large numbers of all nationalities of the world embodied in its citizenship; and these nationalities are gradually, slowly but gradually fusing together into a new nation, the American nation of which we form a part. But during that formative period, and perhaps, after the completion of this fusion each strain that goes to make up that American nation will be preserved as part of their American nationality, the Anglo-Saxon strain, the Teutonic strain, the Latin strain, the Slavic strain and the Jewish strain or nationality. We are not in this country a melting pot in the sense that all the nations of the world are melted into nothingness and only with the exception of one, and that one is absorbing all of us into itself. We are a melting pot only in the sense that all of these nations, all of the members of these nationalities are welded and melted together, that the best characteristics of each of them are brought into the pot for the benefit of the entire mass.

And we Jews, directly as well as indirectly in another way, are giving loyally, as are the other peoples, no more so but no less so, of the best that our centuries have given to us, not selfishly for ourselves but unselfishly for the good of the entire country.

Now, what becomes then of the Jewish nation, of which we form a part, in the true sense of the word “nation?” We feel, we American Jews feel, a brotherhood with the Jews of England and of France and of Russia, a somewhat different feeling than we have toward any other people in the world, due to our common ancestry, due to our common