organization of Jewish fraternal organizations, any more than there is a basis for the organization of Jewish political clubs? They are all of the same sort. They all rest upon the assumption that the Jews are more than a religious community. Of course, Mr. Stern's arguments do not interest those who do not accept his premise. But how will the leaders of the American Jewish Committee meet the stern question which Mr. Stern puts to them?
DEATH OF DR. SCHECHTER
At no time did Dr. Schechter enter into the propaganda of the Zionist movement, for he was essentially a scholar and had no talent for the intricate features of organization and publicity. But when he felt that he could join with the Zionists in their propaganda, he did what he could do well, and wrote an admirable statement of his position. His Zionist statement reveals his ideas regarding Zionism clearly and frankly. He looked, first of all, to Jewish religious influences to maintain the character and consistency of Jewish life. He saw this life subjected to the deteriorating influences of alien environments, and felt that the Jewish religion needed a congenial environment if it was to be maintained with dignity and sincerity. He therefore joined the Zionist organization. He also saw in the Zionist propaganda decided values for Judaism in that it brought back to the Jewish religion and observances many who here otherwise would have drifted further and further away. His animating motive, however, always remained his strong faith in Judaism, and he did not neglect chiding the Zionists in whatever they did which to him seemed to be not strictly religious. He was easily provoked, but his outbursts of disapproval were always subsequently modified with good humor. He was present at many of the Zionist conventions, and while he was remarkably naive in many matters of organization and policy, he always was true to his original conception of the place of Zionism in Jewish life. His death is not only a loss to Jewish scholarship, but also a distinct loss to Zionism. His Zionist influence was beautifully exemplified in the devotion of his estimable wife and all his children to the more practical phases of the Zionist movement.
THE CANADIAN ZIONISTS
The situation of our comrades in Canada since the outbreak of the war has been a peculiarly trying one, but they have managed to maintain a dignified and strong position in spite of it. Their annual convention held last month showed that the movement is maintaining its own and that the Zionists are prepared to make the sacrifices necessary in this crisis. The splendid response of the convention to the appeals of Dr. l.evin and Mr. Brandeis leads us to believe that the war will strengthen the Zionist position there, rather than weaken it. The Canadian Zionists for the first time realized, also, that there are large possibilities for co-operation between American Zionists and their own organization. In line with that realization, the convention adopted resolutions calling for co-operation with the American Federation in the publication of “The Maccabaean” and “Dos Yiddishe Folk.” This was a sensible decision. The Zionists in Canada can profit by the issuance of these periodicals, and in fact we have a large number of subscribers in the Dominion, but it is one thing to be merely subscribers, and quite another to participate in the management and the responsibilities of these two Zionist organs. The President of the Canadian Federation. Mr. Clarence
I, de Sola, was one of the founders of "The Maccabaean," and together with Dr. Gottheil and Dr. Wise, formed the corporation which first issued the magazine. Owing to many technical and organization difficulties, Mr. de Sola retired from active participation in the affairs of the publication. We hope from now on that cordial and fraternal relations will be resumed, and we assure our Canadian comrades that we shall do all that lies within our power to be of service to their organization.
"THE ROMANCE OF ZIONISM"
We have received many complimentary opinions of the article in our last issue contributed by Mr. Philip M. Raskin on “The Romance of Zionism.” Mr. Raskin touched on a phase of Zionist endeavor which is often overlooked by Zionist speakers and writers. We are prone to abjure the sentimental and emphasize the practical, on the theory that we in America are primarily a practical people. But if the youth are to be impressed by Zionism, a little more of the romance of Zionism must be expounded. Most of us are engrossed in the material aspects of the movement, and are unable to see Zionism as a whole, and the impression it will make upon the future Jewish historian. The makers of history are never the best writers of that history. The result is that the outer features of Zionism often appears as rough and materialistic, and the idealistic mind is repulsed by statistics and facts. And yet all the Zionist facts that have been established, taken as a whole, form a romantic story of devotion and self-sacrifice.
THE SENTIMENT FOR ZIONISM
We Zionists have always been speaking of the sentiment for Zionism, which exists among the masses of the Jewish people. It was impossible for us, however, to prove it by figures or in any demonstrable way. We have had to rely upon our intuitive knowledge of conditions. But during the past year, this sentiment has come to the surface in many ways. We see it in the deliberate act of a number of fraternal organizations, which have endorsed Zionism without a dissenting vote. We see it in the Congress movement, which, without our direct intervention, has developed into what seems to be an accessory to Zionist endeavor. When the Zionist organization, in the interests of unity of action, declared for an open program, it was the so-called non-Zionist organizations that insisted upon the inclusion of a Palestine plank. Among the radical workmen’s organizations, the extremists came from elements hitherto indifferent to national aspirations. The sentiment is also tangibly seen in the number of individual lodges and societies that have come forward with co-operative efforts for Zionist projects. A readier acceptance of Zionism is evident in certain Americanized elements from whom we expected at this time a strong antagonism to Jewish nationalism.
This is a condition which demands of Zionists an energetic application to their duties. We must get the fraternal lodges to enter the Zionist movement by the enrollment of their members as shekel-payers. The lodges must be visted by committees, Zionism must be expounded, and an urgent appeal must be made for direct participation in Zionist responsibilities. We must form Zionist groups in every city where none is found to-day. There should not be a town with as few as ten Jews without a Zionist committee. This is work that requires constant application. We hope that organized Zionists will wake up, and do their full dutv.
