The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVII, No. 6 · December 1915
138printed page
scan 1 of 29
Facsimile · scan 1 of 29
Scan of p. 138
Text · transcribed from the scan

EDITORIALS

THE CONGRESS MOVEMENT

The gratifying thing about the Congress movement is the development of Congress organization sentiment in the smaller Jewish cities. The movement obtains notable support from the communities where the Jews are supposed to be far from interested in Jewish matters. With the organization of local Congress committees, the Congress movement frees itself, to that extent, from dependence upon the official leaders of national Jewish organizations, and comes, at the same time, closer to the basic source of responsibility. In view of that fact, the action of the American Jewish Committee, agreeing to a Congress, but refusing to enter a Conference unless it is specifically understood that the Congress shall not be held until after.the termination of hostilities, loses its importance. The Congress movement has proceeded too far to be impeded by a belated conditional consent based upon an arrogant assumption of superior wisdom, and containing within it the greatest danger to the success of the Congress. The Congressists argue that it would be decidedly harmful to the Congress to decide now the important question of the date of the Congress, because no one is in a position now to say when the holding of the Congress would be most advantageous to the Jewish people. They say that the fixing of the date based upon the fluctuating circumstances of the war would result in checking the development of Congress sentiment, and paralyzing all efforts to arouse widespread Jewish interest, deterring even those committed to the proposition from continuing in their efforts to organize the Jewish people in America. They propose therefore to leave the question of the date of the Congress to the Conference of national organizations, which, if it is to be entrusted with far more important questions, certainly will decide the date of the Congress also with wisdom and farsight. Looking at the matter objectively, it does appear as if the American Jewish Committee is still endeavoring to abort the Congress movement, and seeks this way of stemming the tide of popular interest. The Jewish Congress Organization Committee faces a condition, however, which requires the exercise of the best judgment of its members, for there are many Jews who see no harm in fixing the approximate date of the Congress, and are unable to comprehend the arguments advanced against the position taken by the American Jewish Committee. We have faith in the good judgment of the Congress Organization Committee. It will not, we have no doubt, allow itself to be swerved from the straight path of democracy which it entered at the beginning of this important effort to organize the Tews of America.

GREETINGS TO THE KNIGHTS OF ZION

..The annual convention of the Knights of Zion will be held in Chicago at the end of this month. Every indication points to a large demonstration of the strength of the Zionist movement in the Middle West, but in addition to this demonstration, it is expected that a number of special conferences will be held dur-

ing convention week, intended to strengthen the organization. Every one connected with our organization admits that our Chicago comrades have succeeded in winning a dignified and worthy position in the Jewish life of their community, but it is clear that the large territory occupied by the Knights of Zion requires specialization, and intensive operation within a more limited territory by persons more closely acquainted with local conditions. It is to be hoped that the Convention will give due consideration to this problem, and will come to decisions reflecting a desire to aid in the development of the movement by utilizing every bit of power and strength and influence we may possess in its territory, regardless of its effect upon the traditions of the Knights of Zion. We wish our comrades success in their convention. The presence of Mr. Brandeis and of Dr. Levin will doubtless be of great value in solving some of the pressing organization problems of the Chicago organization. The greater activity of the Chicago office due to the establishment of a special bureau, in charge of Leon Zolotkoff, is what Chicago needed for the development of its position.

WHAT THEY WOULD MAKE OF THE JEWS

An able young Philadelphia lawyer, Horace Stern. who is also a Jew, writes a strong letter of protest to the Jewish Exponent against the Kehillah movement. so-called, and against the implications of that movement. He chides Dr. Cyrus Adler, who stands on the platform of the Jews being a religious sect or denomination, with having abandoned that principle when he organized the Philadelphia Kehillah, and he says that if the Jews are a religious denomination, what business have they to organize to protect themselves against hostile immigration legislation. What right have they to treat of strikes between Jewish employers and employees, as a Jewish subject involving a Jewish responsibility? If the Jews are a religious denomination, they should confine themselves to those matters that are essentially religious. Mr. Stern is affhlliated with a reform congregation and probably means religion in the sense of the reform Jew. This line of argument reduces the opposition to Jewish nationalism to an absurdity. There are few Jews who are so consistent. Even Mr. Schiff is sponsor for an organization of Jewish farmers, and at the last convention of that organization, he urged the Jews to leave the large cities and settle in the West. No one will assert that farming is in the least connected with religion, and if Mr, Stern is correct, what business is it of Mr. Schiff whether Jews reside in large cities or in villaees or on farms? What basis is there for the