The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVII, No. 5 · November 1915
115printed page
scan 2 of 26
THE MACCABAEAN FOR NOVEMBER
115

promulgate its gratuitous warnings at this time indicates a lack of understanding of Zionism, and at the same time shows that its friendliness toward Zionism is merely a mask for highly unfriendly and dangerous criticism.

THE FIRST STEP IN CONSTRUCTIVE RELIEF.

The relief work of American Jewry has lacked a clearly defined policy. It seemed to be the impression, up to within recent months, that all that was necessary was to dilate upon the terrible conditions abroad, and there would be a quick and ample response. No conception was formed of the problems of relief; and the conception of the problems of collection was also superficial and tinged with lethargy. The relief committees were content with acting as collectors, stimu- lators to some extent of the contributions, but everything that had to do with the actual work or relief was relegated to “somewhere in Galicia” or “somewhere in Russia.” The sending of Mr. Isidor Hershfield to Europe was a step in the right direction. It is not sufficient to learn of European conditions through visitors or communications from the seat of the trouble. There was lacking in this information the touch of insight which would appeal to American Jews. There was also lacking a comprehensive survey of the entire field; each correspondent or visitor gave a report only on what he had seen on his own special corner of observation. Mr. Hershfield goes with the intention of making clear to American Jews the whole suffering of the Jews, not only in Galicia, in Russia, but wherever the war has devastated Jewish possessions and destroyed Jewish life. His report is bound to be understood, and being understood, it will result in a much larger response to the appeals for help.

Furthermore, it will lead to the formation of a systematic plan of relief, directed from America, and not through absentee committees residing near the lands of desolation. In the work of reconstruction, American Jewry can do a great deal which no other section of Jewry can be expected to do. And there will be need for such reconstructive plans. It is clear even now that the giving of immediate relief is only the first step. The hungry must be satisfied, the naked must be clothed; but, if that were all, the wretchedness of our people would not disturb us so much. It is the after-effects of all this misery that concerns us. The destruction of communities, the breaking-up of institutions, the rehabitation of large masses of people whose normal means of existence have been withdrawn, and who must be provided with other channels of industry. In short, the problem that will confront us after the war involves a gigantic national problem, with its tentacles spread over the map, of Europe. This is a work whch no one branch of Jewry, itself affected by the war, can expect to cope with. American Jewry being peculiarly free from local problems may occupy the position of savior of European- Jewry. From this point of view, Mr. Herschfield is the first in the line of investigators who will have to go to Europe. Others must follow hm and there will have to be a large group of experts engaged in preparing the plans for the work that is to follow.

The Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society is the one immigrant agency which commands the confidence of all American Jews. It has made the interests of the immigrant its chief concern. Inasmuch as most of the work of rehabilitation has bearing upon immigration problems, it is fitting that the Immigrant Aid Society should be entrusted with the preliminary work of in-

vestigation. The society is popular, and deservedly so. It is run on simple, humane lines, imbued with true Jewish feeling, and we have no doubt that when Mr. Herschfield returns, his report will be received and acted upon with the best interests of the Jewish people at heart.

THE VALUE OF PALESTINE.

A large number of persons, who have given little thought to Jewish problems, and who, as a rule, see nothing beyond their own noses, offer objections to the alleged disproportionate amount of relief that is sent to Palestine. They argue that inasmuch as there are about three million Jews affected by the war, and in Palestine there are no more than eighty thousand Jews, the amount of relief to be sent to Palestine should be in that proportion. They forget a number of important items in the situation, which makes the predicament of our brethren in Palestine much more difficult than it is in Europe. In Russia, for instance, we have behind the million or so Jews affected by the war, a large hinterland not only of general resources, but of Jews who are in a position also to render aid to their harassed brethren. The Jews in Russia have also a large number of relatives and friends and land- leute here in this country, whose contributions do not come under the heading of relief, at least is not sent through the relief committees to any large extent. The resources of Russia, of Poland, of Galicia, are not seriously affected by the war. In fact, in those sections where the war has not extended, industrial conditions are, more or less, in a state of boom.

On the other hand, Palestine is an isolated land. It entire economic structure is now paralyzed. It has no hinterland. All its products are exported. Everything it needs is imported. There are no Jews in Palestine who can give of their possessions to their poorer brethren. Rich and poor, all are affected by the industrial and commercial stagnation. Nor have the thousands in Jerusalem formerly living on the bounty of pious Jews in Russia and Galicia anything to hope for from those sections of the world. The Chaluka is practically destroyed. A large part of the money sent during the past year from America to Palestine was in fact the contribution of those interested in the Chaluka, and their contributions fell far below normal conditions, much less being received from America, in that department, than in former years. Looking at the situation broadly, it may be said that Palestine Jewry is in a worse situation than any European Jewry. It is in danger of actual death by starvation.

It is also to be considered that in giving to Palestine we are not giving to the individuals there, but we are helping to maintain a national property. We are providing for the future. Palestine has become a Jewish center. Its life was of value not only to the Jews living there, but in every land where the Jews had a hope for the future. Palestine is our national home, and it should be the business of all Jews to regard it as their first duty to maintain that national home. For that national center, after the war, is a certain haven of refuge for those who may be forced to leave the lands of persecution. Every Jew in Palestine is a national asset; a magnet that draws other Jews into the national life. And Palestine Jewry can be maintained through the crisis. It is not an impossible task to hold together all our possessions. The amount required can and should be provided by the Jews of America.