vocates to meet all elements in the spirit of fairness and without obstinancy. For, as a matter of fact, the individual organizations composing the Congress Organization Committee are committed to the Zionist platform, and have been in favor of an open program. By going into the Conference on the basis of the resolution of the Workmen's convention, the Congress Organization Committee agrees to limit the program within the meaning of that resolution. This does not exclude the consideration of Palestine, but it classifies Palestine as one of the countries involved in the war, where Jewish rights and interests must be protected.
As a result of this combination of parties, it is probable that the long-awaited Conference will soon take place under the joint auspices of the Congress Organization Committee, the National Workmen’s Committee and of such other organizations, not included in the two committees named, who may be willing to co-operate.
THE SIGNIFICANCE OF THE CONGRESS.
There are many friends of the Jewish Congress movement who believe that the value of the Congress rests upon its demonstrative effect upon public opinion. In their opinion, the Congress is to be the climax of a campaign for equal Jewish rights. They grant that the Congress should be organized on a democratic basis; they would prevent its becoming a mass- conference or mass-meeting; but they see nothing in the Congress but a demonstration of the earnestness of the Jewish demand for equal rights. It may be granted that the Congress will impress the world with the earnestness of the Jewish demands, but the question is: How is this impression to be made most effectively? Certainly, it cannot be made if the Congress is to be the occassion for the solemn acceptance of one reolution containing all the Jewish demands. If the impression is to be made through a resolution, there may be other ceremonial methods that may possibly be just as good as a Congress.
The fact that must be borne in mind is this: We shall never be able to make an effective impression upon the nations of the world unless they know that what comes before them in the form of resolutions not only has the desire of the Jewish people behind it, but also their direct and conscious demand, which they are prepared to back up with all the strength they have. There is the fatal weakness of all “stadlon” methods. The “stadlon” rests his case upon the benevolence of the potentate, the generosity of the master. He appeals for succor not because of his strength but as an object entitled to help because of his weakness. The Congress should aim to concentrate Jewish strength in an assembly which, when it acts through its executive officers, wields power. Unless we are prepared to wield power, as much as we may possess; unless we are in a position to say that behind this or that demand the Jews stand with all their possession ready to back up the demand in whatever way may be necessary; all resolutions that may be adopted are worse than mere scraps of paper. That is why the Congress must represent organized strength, not demonstrative achievement. The Congress must be the fortress the Jews erect for the protection of any resolution they may adopt. The Congress must be regarded as the instrument through which demands become effective. It must be taken as the permanent force that will continue its existence until the rights demanded shall be attained.
THE NEW NATIONALISM.
The “Jewish Exponent,” in one of its recent issues, betrayed a confusion of mind which is not habitual with our esteemed contemporary when discussing Zionist problems. While reiterating its endorsement of Herzlian Zionism, it ventures to criticize the new tendencies especially in American Zionism, developed during the past six months. The curious thing in its criticism is that it is not at all clear what it refers to. For in the same editorial it passes over to the discussion of certain demands alleged to emanate from the Jewish Congress Organization Committee regarding the recognition of the Jewish nationality in countries like Russia. We are not aware that any responsible organization has made any demand for the recognition of the Jewish nationality in Russia. In fact, there has been no mention of Russia in relation to Jewish nationality. There seems to be unanimity of opinion as to what Jews need in Russia. They need equal civil and political rights, the abrogation of the Pale of Settlement, the right to reside in any part of the empire. No one has been asking for more than this.
Whatever there has been of discussion about nationality has had to do with Poland, in case that country is rehabilitated as an independent state. It is felt by all who know anything of conditions that if the Poles become the master-nationality of Poland, they will treat the Jews with even greater barbarity and injustice than has been their lot under Russian rule. In order that Jews may be assured of equality in civil and political life it is essential that they be accorded recognition as a national group in Poland. Further, nationality in the Austrian Empire is not a new thing. Austria does recognize the various national groupings in the empire. It is a federation of nationalities. It is hardly probable that any sensible Jew will object to the Jewish demand for equal recognition with the Ruthenians, the Czechs, the Slavs of the Austrian Empire, for if they are not accorded this recognition, of what use is the limited right of civil and political liberty, when every other citizen is not only a citizen, but also a participant in the national ambitions of his own group.
Having vented its wrath against any attempt to acquire national recognition for the Jews in Russia, which no one has demanded, the “Jewish Exponent” turns around and takes up the question of nationality in Turkey, which is also a state of nationalities. Here it discusses the matter quite sanely, but concludes with a gratuitous warning to Zionists and Jews in general not to do anything that may tend to destroy the Turkish Empire. This is attributing a tremendous conceit and foolhardiness to the Zionists. On the contrary, without committing a breach of neutrality, the Zionists have always felt that their national obligation and responsibiliy, as well as their national interests, demanded loyalty to Turkey, and co-operation with its national aspirations.
We have felt, and often expressed the feeling, that in a well-ordered Ottoman empire, the Jews had the best opportunity to develop their cultural and economic life in Palestine. We have rested our policy upon the traditional friendship of the Turks and the Jews. We have assumed, and relied upon the assumption, that the kinship of the Jews and the Turks should allay any suspicions on the part of the Ottomans with regard to our pacific endeavors in Palestine, and that from the Jewish point of view, this kinship gave assurance of a splendid future for the Jewish people in the Orient. For the "Jewish Exponent" to