The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVII, No. 1 · July 1915
29printed page
scan 28 of 42
Facsimile · scan 28 of 42
Scan of p. 29
Text · transcribed from the scan

Mr. I. Kahanowitz of Greensburgh: I intended to speak against this resolution, but when I read the report of the Federation and saw all that it has done during the year, I have decided to speak for an increase in the dues. We cannot ask the Federation to do work unless we provide it with the means.

Mr. Israel I. Wolf of New York: The entire debate is superfluous. Most of the societies have passed resolutions to make it incumbent upon each member to become a subscriber either to The Maccabaean or Dos Yiddische Folk. Therefore I think the only thing to be considered is whether the dues should be increased by 25c.

The Chairman: The substitute motion is now before the house: whether the dues shall be raised to $1.00, to include the shekel, leaving the subscription to The Maccabaean or Dos Yiddische Folk optional.

Miss Szold: I should like to know from the Budget Committee to what extent the increase from 50c to 75c will, in the present circumstances, help the Federation out in covering the deficit.

Mr. Louis Robison: By $1500.

Miss Szold: The change in the per capita tax is going to be extremely difficult for Hadassah; it is very difficult for us to collect the $3.00 dues; and it would discourage us otherwise. However, if the increase of 25c would make a difference to the Federation, I feel that it would be loyal and patriotic on the part of Hadassah to consult with the Executive Committee of the Federation in the hope that by getting expert advice, we might avoid disorganization.

The Chairman: The nearer we get to the ideal that each member should pay in proportion to the budget, the better.

Substitute motion adopted.

The session then closed, with a vote to meet again at eight o'clock in the evening at the regular convention hall in Boston.

FIFTH SESSION.

The final session of the Convention was held on Wednesday evening, June 30, at 8 P.M., in the Old City Club, Boston.

Mr. Lipsky took the chair and granted the floor to Mr. E. W. Lewin-Epstein, who said:

To-day a motion to have Flag Day on Chanukah was defeated. It was under such circumstances that we could not give cool deliberation to the matter. I would therefore make a motion to refer the matter of Flag Day to the Executive Committee of the Federation to decide upon it in consultation with all other organizations interested in it. The National Fund is now in such circumstances that it needs all the money it can get; it is the only branch that is practically alive.

Mr. Israel I. Brodie of Baltimore: The convention having discussed the matter twice already and having decided twice against it, I move that the matter be laid on the table.

Mr. S. Abel of New York: Mr. Lewin-Epstein makes this request after consultation with a number of the people who objected to the motion. It is the wish of those who objected tn have a reconsideration of the matter.

Mr. Brodie: If you are against laying it on the table, you may vote against it.

Vote taken for laying the matter on the table was lost.

The Chairman: The motion of Mr. Lewin-Epstein's to reconsider the matter of Flag Day is now before the house.

Mr. Jacob Zahler of East Boston: I would like to ask if the matter is turned over to the Executive Committee and that committee should decide in favor of Flag Day would it be incumbent upon a society to have Flag Day if it should not want to have it?

Mr Ahel: That is a matter for the society to arrange.

Mr. M. Kolinsky of Cleveland: In Cleveland there was collected on Flag Day $1,100 and Flag Day did more for the spirit of Cleveland than any other kind of propaganda.

Mr. M. Neaman of Pittsburgh: In order to sell flowers on a Sunday we have to have permission of the city authorities; we can get permission for one day, but if we continue to ask

for two days, they may not grant us even one. For that reason we oppose it.

Mr. Nathan D. Kaplan of Chicago: Since we trust the Executive Committee with all our affairs, we can certainly trust it with this thing.

Miss Henrietta Szold of New York: I submit that all these arguments are out of place in connection with Mr. LewinEpstein’s motion. It implies this: we have not had opportunity for calm deliberation at this convention; it means this too: that parliamentary law has been carried too hard to advance the good of the cause. The question is now of placing the matter of Flag Day before the Executive Committee which is competent to judge it, and take into consideration what we have said here for and against it, and I beg you to leave the matter to them. If they decide against it, it will be for the good of the cause, and if they decide for it, it will be for the good of the cause.

Motion to refer to the Executive Committee, adopted.

The statement as finally adopted bearing upon the war situation, which was reported by Dr. Kallen, reads as follows:

“In Europe there rages a war of unprecedented magnitude. All the great nations of that continent are engaged in it and the lesser and neutral ones are suffering from it. „Its effects are felt in the economic and spiritual life of the whole world. AI ceivilization has a stake in it.

“But however great or however small the stake of other peoples in the war, none is greater than the stake of the Jewish people. The national life and characteristic spiritual values of other peoples are not in jeopardy. Whatever state wins, the quality and genius of the other nationalities will be respected and preserved; each will still be free to maintain the continuity of its traditions and be able to give autonomous expression to its unique national spirit in the form appropriate to that spirit.

"For the Jewish people there exists, however, no such assurance. The Jewish problem which obtained before the great war has only been aggravated since the war's beginning. There have been added to the civil and social disabilities of the Jews in several of the belligerent countries the disabilities of war conditions and the unspeakable horror of war practices. There are some seven hundred thousand Jews in all the armies afield. There are some four million Jewish non-combatants in the very seat of the war, in East Prussia, in Russian Poland, in Galicia. Over one-half million of them have been driven from their homes and are wanderers on the face of the earth, without food, clothing, shelter, medicine or decent burial for their dead. Their goods have been confiscated and destroyed; women outraged; old men and young children given over to the hangman. Of all who suffer from the war these Jews are the most needy and pitiable. They have no helpers at home and relief from abroad, however generously given, cannot begin to meet their needs.

"Nor can such relief make any final difference in their situation. The condition in which they find themselves is only the maximal aggravation of an earlier and historic condition. The condition in which they find themselves is only a malignant intensification of a permanent and universal condition with analogues in other countries as well. It is this condition which the expression 'Jewish Problem' designates, and for this condition relief is merely an opiate, not a cure. The cure is the stake of the Jewish people in the great war.

“On the particular issues of the war, the Zionist Organization, of course, passes no judgments and takes no sides. Its members are citizens of every embattled state; the people about whose special fate it concerns itself are fighting with the utmost courage and loyalty in every army, true to their civil and military obligations to the states which they serve, also unto death, even where those states are false to their own solemn obligations towards the parents, wives and children of soldiers, and even toward the soldiers themselves, who die ior their sake on the field of battle. The Zionist Organization is neutral and cannot be otherwise.

“But the Zionist Organization takes this occasion solemnly to point out that the issue in this war is the same for all the belligerents and that this issue is the one on which the