The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVII, No. 1 · July 1915
28printed page
scan 27 of 42
Facsimile · scan 27 of 42
Scan of p. 28
Text · transcribed from the scan

is not with a spirit of antagonism that we assert our opinion. I was of the opinion that once I handed the resolution over to the official body, I had the right to make it public to the press. I regret if I have done the wrong thing.

The Chairman: The fact that the State Assembly does as you say may be quite right; but no one man can speak on behalf of an entire convention. When a resolution is handed over to the press before the convention has acted upon it, the impression conveyed is an incorrect one. It is an attempt to commit the convention in anticipation to the wishes of one or more delegates. It is only after a resolution has been presented on the floor and acted upon that it represents the opinion by the convention.

Mr. Borofsky: I, nevertheless, ask that the resolution be placed before the convention.

The Chairman: Let me explain to Mr. Borofsky. His resolution is: That a committee of ten be appointed by the Chair to define and establish the rights, powers and duties of the Provisional Zionist Committee and the form and manner of representation thereto, and to report the same to this convention for ratification.

The status of the Provisional Committee was fixed by the Inner Actions Comite. This convention has no authority to limit or extend its jurisdiction. It was improper and misleading to hand this resolution over to the press before it was considered by the convention. I therefore suggest that it not be presented to this convention.

A motion to that effect was unanimously adopted. Judge Strassberger of Washington: I move a vote of confidence in the Resolutions Committee for having rejected this resolution. Adopted.

REPORT OF BUDGET COMMITTEE.

The Chairman: Mr. Goodfriend will now report for the Budget Committee.

Mr. Meyer Goodfriend of New York: The Budget Committee begs to submit the following report:

Shekel rebates1,000.00
Special members500.00
Literature income300.00
Income from Dos Yiddishe Folk7,000.00
Income from Maccabaean2,000.00
Federation administrative expenses22.2.222....
Publication Dos Yiddishe Folk ........:10,000.00
Publication Maccabaean2222222222200
Hadassah subvention2.22222

"This shows a deficit of $13,200 which we are going to ask the Provisional Committee to take care of. In view of the fact that the Federation of American Zionists has taken over the publication of Dos Yiddische Folk from the Zion Press Association, it is our intention to ask the Provisional Committee to assume the old liabilities of Dos Yiddische Folk, which amount to $3,632.50."

The proposed opening of offices in Boston, Chicago, etc., as well as the employment of travelling propagandists, will all be referred to the Provisional Committee.

We therefore wish to lay stress on the great need for all Zionists throughout the country to increase their contributions to the funds of the Provisional Committee, in view of the obligations we are referring to them."

Respectfully submitted, Meyer Goodfreund, Chairman. Mr. M. Neaman of Pittsburgh: The financial statement

shows an amount given to the New York Zionist Council. I wish to protest against this; it is the duty of the Council to support the Federation and not the Federation the Council.

The Chairman: This was a loan and not a gift. Mr. S. Landsberg of New York: This amount was given the Council in consideration of several undertakings which the Federation had imposed on it and which involved expenditure which the Council could not meet. Mr. Neaman: The Pittsburgh Council undertook several functions t00.

The Chairman: I wish to call attention to the fact that the budget does not make provision for organizing new Bureaus, etc., leaving this to the Provisional Committee. If we adopt this budget we shall have to ask the Provisional Committee for $13,300.

Miss Henrietta Szold of New York: I wish to say that the $1,000 which is included in the Budget for Hadassah is done without consultation with us.

Mr. E. W. Lewin-Epstein of New York: This was included in the budget of the Provisional Committee.

Miss Szold: If this is meant as a compromise with our per capita tax then we ought to know about it.

Mr. Louis Robison: May I explain to Miss Szold that whether this is voted down or carried, it will not affect the budget.

Mr. Goodfriend: This subvention is meant to provide for the emergency should it arise.

Mr. Aaron Prussian of Washington: Is this budget based on the old per capita tax?

The Chairman: Yes. Mr. Benjamin M. Gross of Birmingham: I move that we accept the budget.

accept th Carried

RESOLUTIONS ON PER CAPITA TAX.

The Chairman: I will read the Resolution on the Per Capita Tax:

Resolved: That the per capita tax for the year 1915-916 shall be two dollars, including the shekel tax.

Mr. Morris Kramer of New York: I do not believe that this is the time to raise the per capita tax.

The Chairman: I wish to call your attention to the fact that the extra income, if this resolution is adopted, is not taken into account by the Budget; therefore it will help us with Dos Yiddishe Folk and The Maccabaean.

Mr. Sam Salz of Cleveland: The conditions in Cleveland do not permit a raising of dues there; and as for the privilege of being a subscriber to Dos Yiddishe Folk or The Maccabaean, why there are people who are members of several societies. I would suggest that the per capita should remain as it is.

Mr. Max Shulman of Chicago: The question of raising the per capita tax is one that should not even have to be debated. If we as organized Zionists do not furnish the funds to our officers, who will? By raising the per capita, we will raise the standard of our organization. If we want to increase our activities, we must increase our funds to work with. The higher per capita will not keep people away from joining societies; on the contrary, it will attract them. I ask you to vote in favor of the resolution.

The Chairman: Are any representatives here who were instructed by their organizations to vote against the per capita tax? (34 delegates responded).

Miss Henrietta Szold of New York: Hadassah has not decided on this subject; it will allow itself to be convinced by the arguments presented here.

Miss Minnie Rose of New York City: I wish to make a substitute motion: that the tax shall be $1.00, including the shekel, and that the subscription to Dos Yiddishe Folk or the Maccabaean shall be optional.

The Chairman: The logical thing to do, since the Federation is in arrears, is to increase the dues. But there seem to be many practical objections. I will therefore allow only those who are in favor of the resolution to speak.

Mr. Abraham Spicehandler of New York: It is the duty of the Zionists themselves to support the Federation and not to call upon the Provisional Committee.