JEWISH LEGIONS GOING TO TAKE PAL- LESTINE.
IT is an indication of the chaos which reigns in Jewish affairs that responsible Jewish newspapers will print, from time to time, reports of Jewish activity in the political field which, if true, should be unreported; and which, if untrue, can do the greatest injury to the Jewish cause.
Such an instance was the publication by one of our presumably progressive newspapers of the report from London that it is rumored in London that Vladimir Jabotinsky, a Russian Zionist, had arrived in England with the object of taking up with the British government a proposal to organize a Jewish legion to fight on the side of the Allies for the freeing of Palestine from the control of Turkey.
The “Day” knew that in all matters relating to political activities on the part of Zionists there is a responsible Zionist committee which has been entrusted with such work. It also knew the names of the members of that committee. Jabotinsky is not one of its members. The “Day” also knew that the policy of the Zionist organization has been expressed time and again since the outbreak of the war, and that any such action as was reported of Jabotinsky was not in harmony with that expressed policy.
But disregarding all this information which it had in its own archives, The "Day" deliberately printed a sensational story emanating from England, and deliberately coupled the alleged action of Jabotinsky with the Zionist organization.
Assuming the story to be true, what should have been the duty of the "Day" as a representative Jewish newspaper? When England projects an important political action, every loyal English newspaper knows that no report of such contemplated action must appear. No censor is actually required. Every patriotic English editor knows that the interest of his country imposes silence. Yet the "Day," even after the Zionist organization had denied the truth of the report, preferred to publish it, with the addition of another rumor manufactured in this country by some irresponsible person.
But the story on the face of it is absurd. Jabotinsky has no army, and had none. He could not speak in the name of an organized movement. There was no sense in offering Iingland the co-operation of a few hundred undisciplined, unorganized Jews in Alexandria, for England could not consider the offer of such service of any consequence. Furthermore, Jabotinsky is not an unknown personage. The characteristics of his public work are wellknown. He is an orator, a writer, with a peculiar penchant for self-glorification. He has exceptional gifts, but these gifts are vitiated by the fact that their possessor lacks poise, a sense of discipline, a sense of order. Jabotinsky is an “infant terrible,” and no one who knows him would agree that he has the gift of political sagacity or the talent for political organization.
There are no Jewish legions willing to fight for Palestine with the Allies against Turkey. The Zionist organization has nothing to do with any scheme conceived by one of its own irresponsible firebrands who, as a
member of the Zionist organization, has been guilty of an absurdity as well as of a disloyal act. Responsible newspaper men know better than to give credence to every wild report that comes to them in a time of war.
TO EVERY MAN HIS OWN JERUSALEM AND ZION.
At first, Zionists used to laugh to scorn the ostentatious declarations of the assimilating Jews, when they boasted, Washington is our Jerusalem and America our Zion or London is our Jerusalem and England our Zion, etc. The pose was taken as one of the necessary formulas of the supersentitive patriotism of the parvenu Americans of the Mosaic persuasion. It was never regarded as a sincere expression of a Jewish ambition, for it was a denial of the cosmopolitan idealism of the alleged liberal religious sect.
But the underlying principle of the assertion persists. It is evident in the pro-Russian sympathies of many Russian Jews, and the echo of those sympathies among the English Jews, who are in the mode when they see nothing to despair of in the Russian Jewish situation, and believe in the Russian promises. The interests of the Jews as a whole play no part in the sympathies of many of our “co-religionists.” They have come to feel themselves as separated in destiny as well as in circumstances from Jews living in other territories. They are humanitarians in their interest in other Jewish life. Altruists who happen to be interested in persons who are descendants of the same ancestor, but wholly unrelated in every other respect.
The man who can repeat, in this day, that "Richmond is his Jerusalem and Virginia his Zion" was not repeating a time-worn gag. He was asserting a fact. Richmond has indeed become his Jerusalem, and the hills of Judea had become insignificant in his eyes, for he sees before him the wide-stretching Virginian hills. He has reduced the scope of his interest. He feels himself out of tune with the world symphony of Jewish life and ideals. He has narrowed his vision and is content for himself and his children and grandchildren, to see no farther than his own cottage door.
The world—which was the "chassez" of the Jew—is too large a place for so small a man to wander in. He wants something more cosy that does not tax his imagination so much. What of the world mission? He would practice it in his own back yard. What of the prophets? He would tell his little congregation about their aspirations, and bid them realize them in the streets of Richmond.
Such men-—there are not many of them left to sing the song—do:not fully realize that in effect they preach the destruction of Jewish unity, the breaking up of the Jewish mission, the abdication of the Jew. They think they oppose Zionism when they preach what they do. Incidentally they do just that, but in a larger sense they oppose idealism, they oppose the Jewish mission, they oppose everything that Jewish life has stood for; they repudiate the heritage of the Fathers and confess themselves bankrupt.