The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVI, No. 5 · May 1915
82printed page
scan 1 of 20
82
THE MACCABAEAN FOR MAY

conscience, undeterred by any false principles or unjust precedents.

Basing his entire argument on technical legal aspects, not speaking as a man, but as a Jawyer, whose one aim was to defeat the proposition, Mr. Marshall proceeded to the absurd when he questioned the evidence of Russian atrocities. He assumed that the demands of a people for justice must be based upon the same rules of evidence as are invoked in a criminal court. In the court of publie opinion, different rules of evidence prevail. When thousands of letters are received here from men and women who tell their stories of cruelty and human rapacity; when eminent men report on what they have seen; when newspapers comment on the facts as reported; and there is no denial or explanation of the reported facts, it may be assumed that a large part of the report is true. They could be substantiated even in a eriminal court, if Russia could be brought before the bar of justice. For the president of the American Jewish Committee to employ such an argument indicates a singular unfitness to discuss questions of vital importance to the Jewish people. It shows that he lacks the imagination to conceive of anything but what he sees in the palm of his hand. Such a man certainly cannot conceive of a Jewish policy, and such a man would naturally be disinclined to enter into a convention where propositions are discussed in a human way.

The proposition calling upon the American Jewish Committee to convene a Congress, together with other organizations, was laid on the table for one month. In the meantime, it may be taken for granted that the American Jewish Committee will not let the grass grow under its feet, but will endeavor to obstruct the expression ‚of opinion by the Kehillah. Mr. Marshall has declared himself opposed to a Congress. Other leading members have committed themselves on the same side. It will be interesting to see what the Kehillah will do after it adopts its resolution and finds the American Jewish Committee unwilling to consider it. According to its own rules, the Kehillah cannot call a’ Congress. It is bound to subordinate itself to the American Jewish Committee on all national questions. What will the members of the American Jewish Committee, who are members there only by virtue of being executive committee members of the Kehillah, do if the Kehillah decides in favor of a Congress? We foresee a conflicet which is bound to produce interesting results.

POLISH PEACE OFFERINGS.

THE Polish National Committee, which regards itself as the future government of a free Poland, has sent a representative to this country with a view to making clear its attitude toward the Jewish question. The delegate, Herr Hausner, took the worst possible means of delivering his message to the Jews of the United States. He gave an address at Cooper Union, supported by an obsolete leader of the anti-national Jewish socialistic party, who offered the resolution. Herr Hausner's blunder may be explained by the fact that he too is a socialist.

He was instructed to say that a free Poland would

give Jews equal political rights. This was the maximum program of his principals, and in spite of urgings from his audience, he would not go beyond his instructions. He declined to state the attitude of a free Poland toward equal national Jewish rights. Whereupon the audience, composed of radical Jews, broke up his meeting.

It should be clear to the Poles that the promise of equal political rights has no value in Poland, where various nationalities contend for their existence. It has no value where the entire Polish population is united in a boycott of the Jews. It has no value where chauvinism reigns supreme, and where the Poles, with great arrogance, insist that their culture shall rule without regard for the various minority nationalities living on Polish territory.

Coupled with equal rights for the Jews is the demand that they give up their national strivings. This may be possible if no one nationality aims to become the ruling power. It might be possible if the Jews felt that the central government intended remaining neutral on cultural questions. But certainly it is unthinkable with the Poles bent on repeating the unjust tactics of the Rumanians. First, equal rights will be promised, but when the question arises as to whom equal political rights may be given, there will be a strong party favorable to considering the race-pure Poles as entitled to the hegemony, and other races as foreigners to the cultural ambitions of the Polish people, and therefore citizens of the second-class. There can be no equal political rights for the individuals of any small nationality, when the majority of the citizens are chauvinistic despots. What will take place is what has taken place in Rumania. Native Rumanian Jews were once legally regarded as natives, but deprived of political rights like the peasants. Then they were classified as foreigners entitled to the rights of foreigners, but being foreigners without influence, with no government to speak up for them. Rumania does what it pleases with them.

It is essential for the safety of the Jewish position in a reunited Poland that they be regarded as a national or racial group. Individual favors cannot be tolerated. The Jew in Poland must be not only free individually, but his group must be free. It must be given the freedom of developing its own cultural values. It must have a right to use its own language, and to develop its own literature and religion. We cannot allow the Poles to seduce the Jewish intelligence with promises of individual rights.

In one thing the Jews can combine with the Poles if their national rights are recognized. They will be loyal to the Polish government, they will regard themselves as integral parts of the Polish political power, and it will be their interest to defend the Polish government and to contribute to its support, having no ulterior political ambitions in view.

If the Poles are wise, if they wish to engage the sympathies of the progressive elements in the United States, if they desire the good will of Jews living outside of Poland, and of the Polish Jews, they will revise their program.