The Maccabaean · Vol. XXV, No. 5 · November 1914
178printed page
scan 30 of 56

danger from prejudices which have to be beaten out thin enough to cover a whole people.

It was Burke, in his speech on the conciliation of America, who declared: “I do not know the method of drawing up an indictment against a whole people’’ Long before Burke, Sir Thomas Browne had written: ‘There is another offence unto charity . . . and that is the reproach, not of whole professions, mysteries and conditions, but of whole nations, wherein, by opprobrious epithets, we miscall each other, and by an uncharitable logic from a disposition in a few conclude a habit inall . . . For by a word we wound a thousand, and at one blow assassinate the honor of a nation.”

The bewildering variety and unanalyzable complexity of every nation is the condition that counteracts the vice inherent in patriotic classification to sharpen and aggravate prejudices. All nations on a smaller plane of culture and civilization have far more that is in common than that is individual. This strong family likeness between modern peoples ensures that there can be no lasting hatreds arising out of patriotism. Jealous and unfriendiy nations are not comparable with cats and mice, or with cats and dogs, each bearing an instinctive, traditional mistrust and hatred against the other. They are all of the same genus and the same type. There are consequentiy no causal, ineradicabie, patriotic hatreds. In these days it is hard to realize that only ten or fifteen years ago England and France regarded each other as historical foes, inheriting a tradition of centuries of active enmity._ Today the peoples of these two lands regard each other as brethren. The relationships of England with Germany, England with Russia, Russia with Japan, etc., and all the modern kaleidoscopic, international courtships or divorces, both in the chancelleries and among the masses, are unstable as water and fleeting and vague as the foam of the sea. Browning’s poem, “It was roses, roses all the way,” expresses the even more patent truth that the hero, today worshipped by the masses as the supreme patriot, next year mav be dragged to the scaffold, branded

as a traitor by the fickle mob. Patriotic prejudices have no stability. There can be little lasting danger from prejudices which, in a constant state of flux, dissolve into one another or break down into favorable prepossessions.

Therefore, we need not fear that Zionism, in awakening Jewish patriotism, will add rancor to the feeling against either the Jew or the non-Jew. Such prejudice as the non-Jew feels against the Jew or as the Jew feels against the non-Jew is, we have seen, inherent in any grouping of peoples. Only our national suicide could remove it. It is not patriotism which kindles the prejudices; it is our defined national existencee. The classification of humanity into Jew and non-Jew trails after it in the mind of either group a certain inevitable prejudice against the other. Though the religious differences involved in the classification may and do stir up prejudices of ominous force, the patriotic differences involved will not add appreciably to such estrangement as may exist. If the possibility that the rebirth of Jewish pariotism will add to or create prejudice be sufficent ground for condemning Jewish patriotism, how much the more strongly must we condemn the religions through which prejudices grow to dangerous proportions. If patriotism must be relegated to the class of evils because of the comparatively weak and ineffective prejudices which grow up under it, then religon also must assuredliy be abolished because of the deep lying and ofttimes violent prejudices which grow up in its name.

The real danger that confronts Zionism as the expression of Jewish patriotism is not that it may propagate prejudice, but that it may become parochial and narrow. Patriotism remains a noble quality until it turns in on itself. In the world today with its universal rapprochement of peoples it is an anachronism to be provincially patriotic. No modern nation can live its own life and develop its own exclusive culture, as if it were isolated on the highlands of Thibet or immured behind a Chinese wall. The intricate network of international trade is proving that Cobden and the first free-traders were right in