The Maccabaean · Vol. XXV, No. 5 · November 1914
177printed page
scan 29 of 56

tionalities peopling the world, are prone to make their lives one paean of patriotic thankfulness that they have not been created like their neighbors. Oliver Goldsmith could write:

"Such is the patriot's boast, where'er we roam,

His first, best country, ever is at home."

There is a characteristic story told of a Sunday school pupil who was asked, "Who was the first man?" "George Washington," he replied, "first in war, first in peace"— "No," interrupted the teacher, "Adam was the first man." "Aw!" replied the lad, "I didn't know you were talking of foreigners." Our patriotisms implicitly exclude, reject and pour scorn on other patriotisms. Civilized human nature has not progressed appreciably beyond where it stood in the time of the ancient Greeks, who genially classified all non-Greeks as "barbarians."

This weakness for excessive contrast pervades all our mental classifications, and is inherent in any mental groupings of individuals or peoples. The danger of exacerbating these inevitable contrasts into prejudices is a real one. Such prejudices may be aggravated into family feuds, social revolution, religious persecution or national wars. But in the case of the classifications involved in patriotism, there is far less danger of pernicious prejudices arising than in the case of religious affiliation. When all that men hold sacred seems to be at stake, when beliefs touching their deepest feelings are in conflict, when sect meets sect and the points of sectarian difference are put into the foreground, a "holy" war is inevitable. It is well when such a clash is limited to literary polemics. But religion may not be branded as bad because in its name so many bitter prejudices have been engendered. Far less may patriotism be branded as bad and barbaric because in its name minor and trivial prejudices have been engendered. The prejudices born of patriotism are indeed few and paltry in comparison with those born of religion.

Similarly we find that patriotic prejudices are weak and sterile in comparison with those arising from individual or family groupings. The bitterest feud

is the narrowest. In the feud between two individual enemies the contrasts are usually most sharply defined. It is human nature to hate a personal enemy with all one's heart, with all one's soul and all one's might. In a family feud the lines begin to be somewhat blurred. A family may be hated in a workmanlike way, but we scarcely regard all the members of the obnoxious family as flends incarnate. When the reference of hostility is considerably broadened, as in national rivalries and disputes, the enmity, in gaining enormously in extension, loses correspondingly in intensity. We can hate an individual; we dislike a family; but for a whole nation our hatred or dislike is thinned out into contempt.

This comparative weakness of the prejudice against a whole nation is due to the endless variety of the elements composing a nation. Even in the inanimate world things can rarely be classified simply and finally under a definite heading. Things are not simply hard or soft, sweet or bitter, useful or useless, etc. There are an infinite number of degrees of hardness or sweetness or usefulness. Absolute hardness or absolute softness is only a mental concept without any corresponding expression in the world of reality. If this is true of inert things, it is far more evidently true of human beings with their infinitely complex personalities. Men are not simply good or bad, or wise or foolish. We are all good and bad, wise and foolish. The maxims of the book of Proverbs which contrast the fool with the wise, or the wicked with the righteous, and the sayings of the Rabbis contrasting the Am Haarets with the scholar, fall with tremendous weight on the wicked, the fool or the Am Haarets, because the antithesis is drawn between those most intolerable, if not impossible, types, the unqualified sinner and the consummately virtuous man, or the absolute fool or Am Haarets and the unmitigated wise man. Individuals cannot justly be defined and classified with this simplicity; and a nation or people, composed of an aggregation of individuals, each of whom is of inextricable complexity, must be of infinite multifariousness. There can be little