The Maccabaean · Vol. XXV, No. 5 · November 1914
175printed page
scan 27 of 56
THE MACCABÆAN
175

noble Aryan did not in the lease affect the controversy, because the Indo-European, ceasing to be a family of languages, became a people and stepped into the Aryan's heritage of all-embracing supremacy. The Aryan's children, the Kelt, the Teuton and the other favored races, began to emerge in beautiful photographic clearness.

Later, anthropometric measurements drove division into these ranks, and only the fair-haired dolichocephalic members of these races were crowned as the bearers of all physical excellences, mental superiorities and moral virtues. Thus the process has continually narrowed itself down into ever smaller and more exclusive classes, until the pseudo-science of race has become little more than academic race prejudice, sowing the wind and reaping the whirlwind. Race theory has become the fertile mother of a spawning brood of jealousies and contempts, antipathies and hatreds, popularly expressing themselves in spurious and blatant patriotisms, and which in the last instance have helped give birth to the bloody passion of licensed massacre which we dignify by the name of war. Zionism, in the over-enthusiasm of some of its youthful converts, in the past has sometimes made a fundamental and fatal mistake by placing itself in line with Pan-Slavism, Pan-Magyarism, Pan-Germanism and similar retrograde and overstrained racial movements of blind pride and unreasoning animosities. Jewish patriotism, if it would disarm attack and purge itself of all traces of prejudices and hatreds, must cease to base itself on the shifting quicksands of pseudo-scientific race theories.

ew \nWe are beginning to understand, from a calm and dispassionate examination of the thousands of anthropometric measurements that have been made and from a thorough sifting of the claims made by the exponents of the psychology of peoples, that race is not a definite, scientific term. The pretentious,

*When Dr. Schulman asserts (Jewish Quarterly Review, New Series V, 198) that "our nationalists take the stand of Chamberlain" on the question of race, he commits himself to a statement which is not only impossible to prove, but which is also a literary intemperance of a prejudice breeding character.

dogmatic and contradictory race theories, with which popular preachers of prejudice, such as Houston S. Chamberlain* have beguiled the "cultured" public, are being every day more thoroughly discredited. We are beginning to see that nationality and patriotism must beware of the smirch of race prejudice masquerading as race theory.

An anthropological study of the endless morphological varieties of the Jewish people, with its long-headed, broad-headed, round-headed; tall or short; fair, brunette, dark or black-skinned members, with snub Grecian or aquiline noses; large, medium or small facial angles; big, medium or little cranial capacity, etc., teaches us unmistakably that the factor of physical race is well-night impotent when in conflict with environment and culture. If race is, as Disraeli claimed, the principle of physical analogy, the Protean Jew can be classified under no heading less broad than that of the human race. The Jericho walls of the so-called science of race, enclosing a mixed multitude of subjectively interpreted physical measurements, irrelevant facts and varying prejudices, fall into tumbled ruins when the Jewish people in its mixed multitude appears before them. The Jew in his physical types is the child of his environment. Hence, the innumerable and widely ranging variations in physical type to be found in the Jewish people. Hence, the utter failure of race theorists to make the Jew fit their Procrustean standards. Hence, also, the barren futility of trying to found Jewish patriotism on any racial theories.

Similarly a psychological study of the Jewish people with its endless varieties and types of character, mind and spirit, teaches us unmistakably that there are as many differing race psychologies of the Jew as there are minyans in Israel.

Although the Jew in some measure takes his mental and moral environment with him in all his dispersion, the modern, emancipated Jew is far more the child of his environment and its culture than of his hereditary qualities. Anti-semitism, or to translate this academic name into its true form, anti-Jewism, in positing a Jewish type of mind and character, posits a nonentity. The Jewish mental and moral types, like the Jewish physical types, fulfill the ancient