hood. The contrast is essential and inherent; and, except for the one who tries to live on all planes of life at once, the contrast is supremely unimportant. Internationalism, nationalism, city loyalty, group loyalty, church loyalty, family loyalty—all are noble ideals. But we need not force and exaggerate the contrast between any of them so long as they co-exist on different planes.
A cinder in one’s eye will blot out a mountain. Family loyalty or tribe loyalty because of their nearness must loom larger to us than the bigger, though remoter, ideals of internationalism or humanitarianism. The more limited the reference, the intenser the feeling it engenders. Family ties can be focussed more strongly than city loyalty. We feel more closely attached to our fellow citizens than to those of another town. We are bound by a closer bond to our native land than to the land of our neighbor. Therefore the broad and diffused internationalism of the Church of Rome, of Socialism or of the Jewish people always gives way when opposed by the intenser pull of nationalism. When Russian, socialist Jews face Austrian or German, socialist Jews on the nationalistic field of battle, both the Jewish international brotherhood and the socialist international brotherhood are well-nigh forgotten. Nationalism is a nearer, more cogent, more appealing impulse than internationalism, just as devotion to one’s parents, wife and children— what we might call “familyism’—is, because of its greater nearness, a more powerful motive force than nationalism. But it does not follow that because devotion to all humanity is good, therefore a specialized nationalistic devotion to a section of humanity is bad, any more than it follows that because a broad brotherhood is good, therefore a specialized devotion to one’s wife and children is bad.
We have now to consider race in its connection with patriotism and Zionism. The racial basis of Zionism is a difficult and controversial question. The pretentious science of race has warped and twisted etymology, anthropology, ethnology, geology, sociology and other
ologies to its own ends. So long as mankind was content to be divided into Shem, Ham and Japhet, the world lived in comparative peace, untroubled by academic questions of race. Overa century ago Blumenbach invented the Caucasian. We Jews did not suffer in the racial estimation of the world by this invention, because we were classed among the Caucasians, the proud standard-bearers in the racial world. But Cuvier, by further subdividing the “Caucasian’” race into the imposingly named Indo-pelasgian, Scytho-tartar and Aramean, succeeded in exciuding us from the charmed circle into which we longed to enter. We were also not altogether happy to be dubbed Melano- chroic by Huxley, although we then stood on the same ground as the Kelt, the South European and the Arab, because we were excluded from the select eircle of the equally formidably named Xanthochroi, the Teuton, the Swede, the Saxon and the other fair white races. But the real trouble began when Max Müller, in a series of brilliant studies in comparative philology, mythology and the Eastern religions, first popularized the Aryan idea. In vain did he warn that “the ethnologist who speaks of the Aryan race, the Aryan blood, the Aryan eyes or hair, is guilty of a heresy equal to that of which a linguist would be guilty if he spoke of a dolichocepha- lie dietionary or a brachycephalic grammar.” The reading public misunderstood and took delight in pointing the relentless contrast between the noble Aryan and the less noble Semite. Other psycho-philologists, such as Renan, summed up the surprising virtues and painful deficiencies of the Semitic character and soul with almost meticulous preciseness. Count Gobineau in his Essai sur l’inegalite des races humaines raised the gospel of racial inequality almost to a religion, one of the ceremonial duties of which was the ex-termintion of the supposediy inferior races. Since the day of Max Müller, Gobineau and Renan, the contrast between the legendary Aryan and the hypothetic Semite has been continually more sharpened and embittered by the Ammons, Houston 8. Chamberlains and Lapoupe. The untimelvyv death of the