Zionists, such as Dr. Lewin, were apt to force the old lieutenants of Herzl into the position of seeming to disapprove of the immediate settlement of Palestine. This was not the fact, however. And in this connection, it is significant that hardly any of the group composing Wolfsohn, Kann, Jean Fischer and the rest but pledged themselves personally to support such “practical” undertakings as the Bezalel, the proposed university, etc.
In other words, there is and can be no question to-day of discouraging work in Palestine, particularly work carried on by private initiative. It is even admitted that the National Fund has created certain institutions in Palestine, has furnished certain types of Jewish life there which are of great value as object lessons, as samples of what may be done. But a business cannot forever be devoted to the creation of samples. The cost is bound to be too great, except to those individually whose gain is a personal one and cannot be computed in dollars and cents. As for the organization, its samples having been created, the way having been shown, manufacturing in quantity must be encouraged, on the one hand, by ceaseless propaganda, and on the other, must be facilitated by the acquisition of the proper facilities for their easy and natural reproduction.
For a great national movement cannot be predicated upon mere licenses superimposed upon archaic or hostile laws and usages. The Zionist Organization must find the weapon suited to its hand and to the situation, perfect it, strengthen it and cleave to it until the time for using it arrives. All else is auxiliary, useful auxiliary, no doubt, but it should not form the principle reliance of a movement so situated and confronted by such conditions.
Of course, if we are to believe with Achad Ha'am that the aim of our movement is only cultural, and that it is possible to create Hebrew culture in Palestine by establishing a small Jewish centre there through
the agency of a modicum of Jews as though it is possible to establish a distinctive national culture anywhere without the deep foundation of a great work-a-day, national life beneath it!—then we may rest content with the hundred and odd thousands of Jews we have in Palestine today. But if we think of Zionism as offering the word of release to at least the seven or eight millions of Jews who are gasping under the merciless pressure of the screws put upon them by their enemies, then our outlook must be another outlook and the methods in use all too insufficient.
It is true that Political Zionism as Ussischkin charged, does not have its centre in Palestine, as yet; that is, it does not commit its fortunes to the success or lack of success of the work done there, valuable and necessary as this work is. It considers that the relation of Palestine to Constantinople is as the tail to the head and it prefers to deal with the head in negotiating the tail, it I may put it that way. It is true that during the reign of Abdul Hamid, colonization in Palestine received small encouragement. But then there seemed almost daily possıbilities of obtaining radical concessions, and it was the part of a consistent statesmanship not to promote colonization pending negotiations. Today the situation is changed. On the one hand, it has not been demonstrated so far thaı a fund such as Herzl contemplated can be raised as quickly as he had hoped; and, on the other, the political status of Turkey has been re vealed as standing in such serious jeopardy recently that it is only the part of prudence for the Jewish people to obtain their foothold in Palestine as soon as possible, in order to obtain whatever advantages accrue to the holders of the soil in any given political readjustment which may take place.
I said that Political Zionism, Modern Zionism, that is, did not have its centre in Palestine. This (Continued on Page 301)