cannot help standing for them at all times, they constitute the real, the permanent leaders of Modern Zionism. It may be true that conditions and opportunities in Palestine today find them too uncompromising, too much out of joint, and they are therefore side-tracked for the time being, and other more limber men are put in their place, but their real position in the movement will remain the same.
And it is quite clear that most of our brothers in the Diaspora, and in Russia, in particular, are not in a position to understand or adhere to Herzlian or Modern Zionism with the same readiness as Jews bred in lands where governments are less despotic, less distrusted and feared and where questions can be brought out into the open with greater freedom. The idea of reaching or being able to reach at a modus operandi with a Government before embarking in any given undertaking is not one that comes very readily, say, to a Russian Jew, and very naturally so. In Russia everything is done while the government is not looking or not objecting. The trend of the multitude of anti-Jewish laws is to make normal activity for the Jew prohibitive; and the resultant influence on the Jew, for which the Russian Government is responsible, is not the least of those crimes which Zionists will find it hard to forgive. The outlook on large undertakings which such an experience is apt to engender is not the kind to bring to bear on the great problems which confront the Jewish People, even if these qualities are united with stronger and more promising characteristics as in the person of M. M. Ussischkin. Nor would it be correct to make this criticism of the Russian Jews only. It is a defect which has its roots in the Diaspora itself, and it is because the political group I have mentioned are devoted to the idea of raising the Zionist movement from the slough of the pre-Herzlian influence of the Golus that they represent the most healthful and promising element in Jewry today.
The fight at the Vienna Congress centred around the attempt of the Administration to obtain a greater measure of control of the Jewish Colonial Bank from the members of the former Administration who were at the head of that institution. This was the ostensible conflict; and let me say now, that no petty or unworthy motive was discernible at any time in the affair. The fight represented an alignment along opposing principles purely, and the underlying principles were these; the belief of the Political Zionists, on the one hand, that the money in the National Fund should be conserved as far as possible against a time when it can be used more advantageously either in obtaining large concessions or in investment in Palestine after the concessions shall have been granted, and, on the other hand, the determination of the Practical Zionists, under the able leadership of Ussischkin, to loosen the check of the Bank and its subsidiary institution, the Anglo-Palestine Bank, on the National Fund so as to permit of a greater measure of immediate activity in Palestine. These conflicting points of view were reflected of course in the criticism of Max Nordau before the Congress and the debate as to the tenor of the message to send him, in the opposition to the choice of Wolfsohn for the presidency, in the criticism of the so-called lack of activity of the Anglo-Palestine Bank, not to mention the Jewish Colonial Trust, in the attack on Ruppin’s report on Palestinian activity, lead by J. H. Kann, in the criticism of the management of Die Welt and in all the attacks, defences and counter-attacks which took place at the Congress. It may be remarked, in passing, that, considering that the Congress houses practically all elements in Jewry, from the radicalism of the Socialist-Zionists to the ultra-orthodox element represented by the Misrachists, the debate confined itself with remarkable fidelity to the broad issues and was singularly free from smaller, personal differences.
The opponents of the Political