The Maccabaean · Vol. XXII, No. 5 · November 1912
145printed page
scan 17 of 48
Facsimile · scan 17 of 48
Scan of p. 145
Text · transcribed from the scan

coctions. Present day Reform must either stop short of its necessary conclusions or else render them invalid as norms of Jewish life. To include all the vagaries of modern reform under Judaism is to make of language an instrument, not for the expression of human though, but for its concealment. Reform as it has manifested itself heretofore, is merely a theological spore, a one generation stage, the belief of the single generation of a family on its way from Judaism to ethical culture, unitarianism or any of the platitudes of recent creation.

* * * * *

But Israel still lives and it lives in spite of the oppressor without and the confusion within.

* * * * *

The beginning of the Goluth marked the supreme exercise on the part of the Jew of what unique human faculty—the differential between man and other spieces—of creating his own environment instead of physical migration to a new one. The story of our people for the past two thousand years is the tale of a people setting up its own goals and forging tools to achieve them. The writing of the Bible by Ezra the scribe, the compilation of the Mishna, the amplification of the Halacha, the founding of the schools at Sura and Pumbeditha, the Jerusalem Talmud, the Babylonian Talmud, the Commentators, the fixation of the Law in Karo's Shulchan Aruch, in short Rabbinism, Kabbalism, and Chassidism all are the instruments for the creation of a specifically Jewish environment. How remarkably well they accomplished this result, the disappearing Ghettos of only yesterday attest.

To-day Judaism faces the supreme crisis of its history. The Ghetto walls have crumbled. Our Jewish counter-environment has yielded in place before the irresistable force of cosmopolitanism, and emancipation and the seductive lures of tolerance and assimilation. The outer world and its large problems have called thousands of young Jews into the arena of life. And they answered. But in the service of the many causes, social, scientific, aesthetic, Jewish culture has been ruled out of their lives. The intense demands of modern life require the narrowing of personality to the knife-edge of efficiency. And to-day you find your Marxs, La Salles, your Ehrlichs and Michelsons and their innumberable followers verily exiles from the hearths of their people and faith.

How long this intellectual depletion can continue without having its double effect on the deserting sons of Israel and on their Mother is a matter saddening to contemplate. From every school and shop in the diaspora, where the Jew is adapting himself to the environment, a Bath-Kol re-echoes, the eternal question of Jewish history, Death or adaption. assimilation among the nations or the return to Palestine, the home of our fathers, the land whose spirit lives in all our literary possessions. These are your alternatives, yours is the choice.