sports, freaks, or sudden trends in stable species. All development must proceed along the lines imposed by the essential nature of the organism. Israel must contribute to the harmony of the nations. The descendants of the Prophets cannot escape the duty which their past imposes. In the eternal struggles for righteousness, for the defense of the weak and the helpless, the widow and the orphan, the sons of the presecuted martyrs of other centuries must not be relegated to parts as hewers of wood and drawers of water to the nations.
The perplexing Jewish question of to-day is:
"Has the Jewish people the will to live in order to play its own part in this drama of history?"
* * * * *
The one great crisis of our national life was the destruction of Jerusalem and the dispersion. How have we reacted? What has been the result? On the open pages of history is recorded our answer. It has been in part death, and in part adaptation.
Shrouded in mystery is the loss of the ten tribes, the proselytization of the Essenes, Frankists and the Sabbatians, and the absorption of the Karaites. The muse of history to-day is playing a dirge over the passing of the reform wing of Judaism, from Henrietta Herz and Dorothea Mendelsohn down to innumerable names of those that withdrew their allegiance from the Jewish faith and its ideals by intermarriage, and by deliberate abstention from its religious life. To these, succumbing benignly to the anaesthetic that time administers must be added those fiery souls that wrote their confession of faith in blood across the scroll of history, in crusade inquisition and massacre. Both answered the challenge of the environment by extinction, individual as well as national.
Adaptation was the other reply to this change of environment. Elements of foreign culture have ever made their way into Jewish life. Hellenism was ushered in by Philo; Mediaeval philosophy by Saadiah; Aristotelean philosophy by Maimonides. The immanent theism of Averroes and the substance and attributes of Descartes were linked to Jewish concepts in Spinoza's works. Modern reform typifies adaptation par excellence. Its Judaism, chameleon-like, takes its color from every philosophic tendency of the day. Hegel's Idealism, Compte's Positivism, Spencer's evolution and latterly James's Pragmatism, all in turn have tossed reform free from its moorings as in a tempest. What the philosophers are cogitating to-day, reform will proclaim to-morrow.
Now, adaptation if carried to its logical conclusion spells death. In sooth, abstract Biology contemplates only life per se; the forms of its manifestation concern it but little. To the biologist, the series embracing reptile, then archaeoptrix, then bird, represent an adaptation to the environment expressing itself in the evolution of a new species. True, the first species is lost. But life itself remains, albeit in an altered, nay, in a new and unrecognizable form. But to us who observe not as biologists objectively and dispassionately, but as Jews with the basic instinct of self-preservation, the Jewish people and its fundamental beliefs cease to be specifically Jewish when they are diluted and re-diluted in exotic con-
