The Maccabaean · Vol. XXI, No. 12 · June 1912
332printed page
scan 14 of 38
332
THE MACCABÆAN

Dane, and Norman, come all from the same ethnic stock. The Jews themselves, admittedly a superior race, are relatively pure; and the same is true of the Scandinavians, physically considered the finest specimen among mankind. Such evidence is obviously not conclusive, but it is the best attainable and unmistakably discouraging. Amalgamation promises the possible potential result of a race combining the objectionable features of the constituent elements.

To a Jew this seems like a doleful solution. It is actually a surrender,—peace at the price of non-existence; and idealistically—morally—it is more revolting than the passive non-resistance of the fatalist. But even if the indulgence to sentiment, as noble as it may be, were subordinated to the practical phases of the problem; and even if eugenically amalgamation were not draught with possible dangers, even then absorption is not justifiable. If the Jews are a superior race and their mingling with the rest of mankind would tend to improve humanity, their number in the world is so small relatively, that whatever distinctive contribution they might make, in the end would be diluted infinitesimally among the races of the world and fall into utter insignificance. A force would thus pass out of the world. As a separate homogeneous people, however, with characteristic institutions of their own, and permitted to evolve according to their own impulsion, they can contribute to the world their own art and their own culture; and thus add their might to the ultimate realization of mankind. Absorbed—they are a little thin stream lost in the sea of humanity; distinct—they can add to the forces toward good.

It would seem, thus, that sociologically considered, these two possible solutions, inactivity, and amalgamation, are both unsatisfactory. The third alternative is occupational separation. The source of ill-feeling arises from the presence of large numbers of one group of distinct people with another; heightened, primarily, by the economic competition resulting. If this competition could be avoided; if each race or group were to have its own series of occupations, establishing, thus non-competing groups; and neither encroaching upon the peculiar field of the other, the source of friction would be undermined and peaceful cooperation would tend to

follow. This is actually said to be the case on the western coast of this country where the Chinese have monopolized certain businesses—chiefly laundrying. The same is true with the caste system in some parts of the world. This form of solution in such problems, however, is becoming less possible. As progress advances the tendency to enter occupations of every character, without discrimination, is growing rapidly; and rigid separation according to race characteristics is becoming increasingly difficult. This is very readily exemplified by the case of the negroes in the southern states of the country. Hitherto, occupations of a certain inferior character were relegated to them. But this arbitrary boundary is gradually disappearing; and white men are slowly entering occupations of every description, bringing the negroes into direct competition with themselves. This is generally the movement throughout the world. And as for the Jew, occupational separation has already been his lot; not indeed that some specific work was reserved for him particularly, but through a process of elimination, accomplished by forbidding him to enter occupations known to be especially desirable, either through the social esteem connected, such as professions; or through their lucrative rewards, such as the ownership of lands. The obvious inhumanity of such occupational separation has condemned itself with the leading nations of the world. But even if occupational separation of some nature were possible, this solution will hardly recommend itself to the Jews. To be confined to one kind of activity, generation after generation to eternity, would be both wasteful and narrowing. First, such a program would fail to benefit by the particular kind of ability of each individual,—a possibility which is the heritage to mankind from the increased division of labor; and further, the narrowing would spring from the leveling of the race to one kind of efficiency, precluding possible variation. Again, the Jew would hardly content himself with the special kind of work the world would be willing to surrender to him. It will not be, one can be certain, an occupation especially exalting, or one to occasion envy. Thus—stifling the Jew into prescribed work is neither possible nor desirable.

With passivity, absorption, and occupa-