The Maccabaean · Vol. XXI, No. 12 · June 1912
331printed page
scan 13 of 38
THE MACCABÆAN

peoples, competing together, dislike and distrust each other.

Such is the prospect before the Jews inferred from conditions as they have manifested themselves in the past. But new forces, hitherto unexpressed will, in the future, give the law of "Consciousness of Kind" an added impetus in its unfavorable operation against the Jewish people in this country. Through centuries of oppression, or possibly through native ability—whatever the cause may be—it is admitted they have developed a certain power of resistance and hardhood, a certain kind of efficiency, which has enabled them to survive and maintain themselves with considerable success. Despite prejudice and injustice, the capacity to compete with their fellowmen on a criterion of personal merit has enabled the Jew, often, to achieve positions of high esteem and respect. But that kind of ability by which the Jew has progressed is playing a diminishing role in the evolution of our institutions; and from a system of individualism, we are tending towards a system of collectivism. We are rapidly socializing our activities; and whereas now, and in the past, success was commensurate with intrinsic ability, in the future it will be modified by the general regard and approbation of the community. This in the last analysis means political power. The further social control progresses, the more essential will be the mutual trust and good will of fellow-men; and it is exactly the absence of these in the relations between the Jews and their brethren, owing to a consciousness of difference, throughout history, which has been the source of the Jewish problem. Therefore, as individual merit is gradually subordinated to social esteem, as political power is substituted for personal power, the hostility arising from "Consciousness of Kind" will have a growingly wider scope for expression; and, as the socialization of our institutions continues, the hardships of the Jew will constantly increase.

There are those who are yet sanguine enough to believe that in this country there is still hope of obviating the unfavorable operation of the law of "Consciousness of Kind" Education, in this country universal is expected to give the solution. There are two empirical facts which frustrate this hope. First, the lower strata of society,

the portion of the population to whom future hostility may be attributed, the ignorant and unsympathetic class always remain in its lethargy; not that the people do not rise, but they are always replenished by the incoming flood of immigration. Culture thus never really reaches the bottom. But it has not always been the untutored alone who have displayed the intolerance arising from "Consciousness of Kind." The violent anti-Semitism among the German universities, shows this prejudice to be deeper than ignorance. It is physiological, and inexorable as hunger.

This then is the condition, and the human law at play. The Jews are fragmentary people, eternally surrounded by a hostile environment.

There are four possible solutions to this problem, as to any problem arising from the social law of "Consciousness of Kind." The first solution is really no solution at all. It lies in the attitude of complete indifference. Such is their lot; and the Jews may as well submit to it as we all do to many another unpleasant prospect in our lives,—with the ultimate tragedy of death as the climax. This is probably a tenable position; and whoever can discover consolation in it, must be permitted to enjoy it. It is, however, a philosophy of fatalism and inactivity; and it is just as deadly to this problem as to any problem in human life. It is unmanly and self-centred; and does not deserve serious consideration.

The second solution is absorption. The antagonism arising from consciousness of difference can be dispelled by dispeHing the difference. This can be done through intermarriage. Let the Jews lose themselves among the races and become part of the flesh and ‘blood of their neighbors; let them amalgamate with their gentile brethren, and there is no longer a problem. This is at best a doubtful expedient. The science of eugenics is not clear as to the results of race mixture, but the weight of testimony is not favorable. In animal life the mixture of two distinct breeds is unquestionably bad. The product has been found to be mongrel, of a primitive type, of a nondesript nature. All the great races are relatively pure, raising a presumption against indiscriminate assimilation. The English, though a composite of three <parate original races, the Saxon,