and live disconnected from one another. Numerous enemies both within and without its ranks contest its right to existence and suppress its will to live. Zionism does not look with the question of Judaism but looks for the solution of the Jewish question in a political and territorial way. Socialist Zionism fathomed more deeply the social and economical conditions of the Jewish proletariat and their migratory tendencies, and deduced from all these abnormalities once more the necessity of a Jewish land. But it did not transcend the limits of social and economical investigation.
Zionism, however, independent and abstracted from Judaism is erroneous and worthless. When Judaism has no higher value for universal culture, when the Jewish state has no mission to realize a great human idea, which must be sought in the depths of Judaism, there can be no motive and consequently no real prospect for Zionism. Especially as Zionism in the historical process of its realization does not change the situation of the Jewish nation at large. From where should Zionism draw forces for its heroic effort? The highest ideal of Zionism cannot be the evasion from oppression as there are so many other ways for scores of Jews to evade oppression which would work practically more efficiently than Zionism. Zionism can only be the consequence of a higher vauation of Judaism and an effective means not only of freeing the Jewish nation but of embodying the sublime substance of Juda-
ism in concrete national forms.
The question as to what is the substance of Judaism has become therefore the most vital problem for the Jews of our time. From the solution of this problem depends the line of development of Jewish history in the future. Judaism has to prove its value and even its superiority before the tribune of modern culture, so that it shall be able to maintain a position in universal history. From the greatness of Judaism the Jewish nation can get its justification and even its sense of duty to further its national life.
The Jewish nation manifested itself historically in religion, philosophy, ethics, ideals, forms and institutions of life. Certainly, all these phenomena and ideals were liable to change and transformation, but in all change and varieties the nation showed historical continuity. By the interweaving of phenomena and ideas of different epochs with the creative work of the individual, unity was brought about in the expression of the national spirit. The differences of epochs and historical conditions, the individuality of thinkers vanish in the face of the inner connection of the phenomena which reflect the marvellous inner unity of Jewish history. Thus, the eternal acquisitions of the Jewish spirit in its manifold historical manifestations we can consider as the substance of Judaism. And the creative forces of this Judaism for the present and future are the reason and justification of the Jewish nation and its aspirations in universal history.