another, so that Jewish history is, perhaps more than the history of any other nation, a continuous one. And the thinkers and teachers who formulated and created Judaism, differed in character and mode, but the air they breathed was the same, their life-blood flowed from a common source and one heartbeat throbbed in their pulse. They were inspired by the same ideal.
But what is this marvellous essence of Judaism and what part of it is to be emphasized so that Judaism shall become a creative force in modern culture? That ritual Judaism is not the substance of Judaism is clear from the striking fact that even in the time when Judaism was contained in the huge folios of codices and ritual text-books, rigid conservatives were apologizing for the "sinners of Israel." But even the purer religion of "liberal Judaism" cannot be considered as the substance of Judaism in our times, as Renan's well known utterance that "Judaism is a minimum of religion" is rather true. It hits the mark not only in the sense that Judaism demands fewer articles of faith but, also in the sense that its centre of gravity is not to be found in the formal religious sphere. For the scores of Jews who become indifferent and even consciously hostile to religion cannot be excluded from Judaism so as to have "no part in Israel." Otherwise the Jewish nation would be reduced to a small minority and even the resigned word of the Prophet "a poor and lowly people shall be left in the midst of thee" could not find more fulfillment.
Many modern nationalist Jews in their hostile or indifferent attitude to any suggestion of giving an adequate definition of Judaism, reduce Judaism to the cultural features of the modern Jewish nation. The Jews, they say, are not a political nation but they are a cultural nation with so many na-
tional features and Judaism is the manifestation of the modern Jews. Judaism is empirical Judaism as it is manifested in the main features of Jewish life. That is the standpoint of the modern prolitarian or socialist nationalism, which considers the Jewish masses as the real Jewish nation and the Yiddish language of a part of these masses as the only real Judaism, as the real Jewish culture. The socialistic and cultural development of the Jewish proletariat in the "Yiddish" language is the final meaning of Jewish nationalism beside which Judaism is a historical anachronism.
It is a standpoint which is full of inconsistencies. The conception of the Jewish nation and the Jewish culture is here intentionally narrowed. The Jewish nation is pressed into the limits of the Yiddish-speaking proletariat, whose temporary cultural needs are proclaimed as the modern meaning of Judaism. This conception which deserves criticism only because of its transitory popularity among scores of Jewish radicals, is a passing one and lacks any scientific basis. What is or shall be the function of this Yiddish nation and Yiddish Judaism? From what period does the beginning of Jewish history date? Does it transcend the origins of the Yiddish literature as the Jewish nation transcends, perhaps, the limits of the Jewish-speaking proletariat? This whole conception is a transitory political standpoint, adapted to the special phasis of the revolutionary propaganda among the Jewish workingmen.
Nor is Zionism in any of its forms an answer. Zionism deals with the Jewish question, but not with the problem of Judaism. The Jews have the glory and the aspirations of a historical nation, but now they are a disorganized social body whose members are scattered through all parts of the world