to determine exactly which class of Jews is the true, pure, original race. The diversity of the anthropological type among Jews, which has just been described excludes classification of the kind" (p. 152). But how far this so-called "diversity of type among the Jews" is to be trusted as a racial test, we shall see when we come to the question of type.
To what extent, however, Mr. Fishberg can stretch the point in his favor, may be seen in the chapter "Mixed Marriages in Modern Times." Here he finds himself, indeed, at a great disadvantage.
For here there are statistics, and statistics plainly show that the losses of the Jews by intermarriage are enormous in contparison to their gains by it, and, moreover, that these gains are so insignificant that they cannot in the least affect the racial traits of the Jews. Mr. Fishberg himself admits that no marriages can legally be contracted between Jews and non-Jews in the countries where the greatest majority of the former lives, unless consequent upon conversion of the Jew. He, moreover, finds that even in those countries where intermarriage is legal, only some ten percent. of the children born of interMarriages revert to Judaism. Yet, here, too, Mr. Fishberg knows a way out of the difficulty. ‘The ethnic effects of intermarriage,” he says “hetween Jews and Christians must not be underestimated. We have shown that comparatively few of the offspring born to mixed parents remain within the fold of Judaism, in the long run, hardly more than ten percent. But it must be born in mind that the number keeps on increasing and is cumulative. It is consequently to be expected that in the course of years new anthropological types are being introduced among 6 children of Israel (p. 219) How so? one should like to ask. If the ten percent. that the Jews gain by intermarriage is perhaps merely one percent gain from the whole number of Jewish marriages, and this also in countries where the minority of Jews live, how then, can this gain be cumulative? And thow will a new anthropological type arise from it among the Jews so as to change their racial characteristics? This is a scientific mystery obviously known to Mr. Fishberg alone.
II
The chief arguments upon which Mr. Fishberg bases his theory are, however,
the somatic, or physical , characteristics of the Jews: stature, the head form, pigmentation, or the color of the hair and eyes, and the general cast of face, in all of which there are great variations among the Jews of the different countries. As regards stature, Mr. Fishberg is somewhat shaky. At first he combats, and with some justice, the opinion that the smallness of stature among the Jews is a mere racial characteristic, but holds that it is tather due to alimentation and environment. He points to the fact that whereas the Jews of Lithuania, for example, show an average of 161.2 cm. in height, the native Jews of England are almost as tall as the average Englishman, 171.4. ,וש and the children of Jewish immigrants in New York average 167.9 cm. in height whereas their parents average 164.2 cm., “an increase of 3.7 cm. in ‘height in one generation.” But thesq facts would not be quite in accord with Mr. Fishberg’s theory that the Jews are merely a religפטסו sect, which has recruited its members from the different non-Jewish peoples. For if we once admit that stature may be influenced by environment, then we may easily explain also the variability of stature among the Jews of the different countries; and Mr. Fishberg’s theory would remain with an argument less in its favor. Ife therefore, turns immediately about and remarks: “It is evident(?) that the shortness of their stature can only to a slight extent be attributed to the intluence of the environment in which thev find themselves or to the occupations in which they mostly engage” (p. 44) but that it must also be attributed to the admixture of foreign blood. How it is “evident” is not quite clear. The very data that Mr. Fishberg himself brings in that connection from the native English and .\merican Jews subvert this “evident” theory. Or is, here, too, a case of admixture of foreign blood? But he cited his own measurements, where he found the difference in height between the immigrants and their own children! And is here not a clear case of the 66ת6טהתה of environment? And if so can we not explain in the same way the fact that the mountain Jews of Dhagestan, for example, are taller than the Lithuanian Jews? The conclusion of Dr. Fishberg, therefore, as regards ethnic influence in connection with stature may be regarded as unfounded hypothesis.
(To be concluded.)