The Maccabaean · Vol. XXI, No. 2 · August 1911
42printed page
scan 14 of 26

ers rage against them. But if we study the question at closer range, we can eaSily see that these “conversions” did not result in the junction of foreign elements with the Jewish race, so as to affect its characteristics in an appreciable degree. In the tirst place, even Josephus speaks more of partial conversions, or rather of a mere influence of the Jewish Law, than of full conversions, (Apion II, 39), and he also speaks, moreover, of relapses to heathenism. (ib. II. 10). Secondly, it is a well known fact, that complaint of the Greek and Roman authors of the numerous conversions to Judaism, refers to a great, if not to the greatest, extent, to Christians, who were regarded as Jews, inasmuch as Christianity also originated in Palestine. Thirdly, even in cases of ful] conversion, the prosclytes did not always intermarry with Jews, but remained in their previous heathenish family relations, so that their children probably did not share their parent's attachment to Judaism—and this is also true of the noted Roman convert, Fulvia. Fourthly, it is precisely that element of converts to Judaism—and this is also true of the Hellenistic Jews—from which Christianity later drew its numerous adherents? If, however, the absolute purity of the Jewish race may have been affected by these conversions, it is a gross exagyeration to assert that the Jewish race was submerged under the overwhelming numbers of the proselvtes coming from other races.

Fishberg consistently overdraws also the extent of conversions and intermarriages during the Middle Ages. He finds individual cases as well as conversions of whole tribes and peoples. The Yemenite Jews, the Falashas, the Black Jews of India, Chinese Jews, the Chazars,- all these are enough, according to Mr. Fishberg, to silence forever the claim of the existence of a Jewish race. Now, as for the proof from individual cases, we may discard it as worthless, as far as affecting the characteristics of the Jewish race is concerned. The exclusiveness of the Jewish religion, on the one hand, and, on the other hand, the restrictions of the Christian church were the strongest barriers against closer racial contact. Of the con-

version of whole tribes and peoples, let us consider first the case of the Chazars. Here opinion differs very greatly as to the number that embraced Judaism, some historians maintaining that it was rather in small comparison to the number of Chazars who adopted Christianity or Mohamedanism, or who remained heathens. At any rate, the Chazars, after the destruction of their kingdom by the Russians, certainly did not amalgamate with the Jews to such an extent, as to make a strong racial impression upon the latter. Most of the Chazars probably dissappeared through assimilation with their conquerors and the neighboring peoples. Some of them formed the nucleus of the Karaites and probably also of the Subbotniki (a Judaising sect in Russia). And, of those that were merged with the Jews, the proportion must have been so small, that they did not even leave a trace of their language to be filtered through later into the Jewish vernacular (see Jewish Encyclo., art. Chazars and references).

Concerning the Yemenite Jews, the question is still more ohscure. Those who are of the opinion that the Yemenite Jews are of Arabic origin, depend mainly upon the physical characteristics of those Jews, which resemble those of the Arabs. But these characteristics did not leave any margin for the racial relationship between the Arabs and the Jews; secondly, that physical characteristics are not a sure and unfailing racial test, we shall see later. A clearer case seems to he that of the Falashes? the Chinese and the Indian Jews. who diverge so much from the type of the modern Jew in Europe and America, as to warrant the assumption, that they are descendents of the native non-Jews, who adopted Judaism. But if this be so, it would simply justify the opinion of Jacobs and others, that the Jews may be divided into three classes: Jews by race and religion (the Jews of Europe, America, Australia, and the near East), Jews by religion but not by race (the Jews of India, China, Abyssinia, and_ possibly, Yemen), and Jews by race but not by religion (as the Crypto Jews of Turkey). Fishberg, however, rejects this classification. “At present, he says, this classificnrtion is untenable, because it is impossible

3As regards the Falashas, see however, the opinion of Dr. Faitelson.