vious kind. It may have filled his soul with an ecstacy of satisfaction to feel that in this elaboration of religious precepts, he was obeying the will of God, a feeling which could not help but produce a sense of vain self-esteem and self-righteousness which deflects from the true Jewish ideal. Shulchan Aruchism could make saints and devotees, but not statesmen or prophets.
I think it also necessary to mention what Prof. Ginsburg in his article on Joseph Caro in the Jewish Encyclop ædia is careful to point out, that the publication of the code was due to the new situation created by the expulsions of the Jews from Spain and Portugal. When the exiles came to the various communities in the East and West where different usages and customs prevailed the questions naturally arose whether the new comers, the majority of whom were men of greater learning than the local authorities, should be ruled by the latter or vice versa. The result was that many felt justified in following their own sweet will and a confusion of customs began to prevail. It was this condition of things that Caro undertook to remedy, and so set himself the task of writing and compiling his monumental work. The cause therefore for the compilation of the Shulchan Aruch is strangely enough the same which compelled the initiation of the Reform Movement here —the immigration of large numbers of Jews forced by persecution to seek new homes and creating in their new environment problems which called for new solutions. The situation thus created is very familiar to the student of history and need not be enlarged upon. But what marks it as different from any other similar situation in history is the stubborn and determined opposition—beginning in its earliest stages at the time of Mendelsohn and Geiger—waged by the adherents of Orthodoxy against all and sundry who sought to adjust the religious fabric of Judaism to the new mental and material conditions. This attitude assumed by Orthodoxy is utterly untenable, if not altogether foolish and ostrich-like. It refuses to see in the completely transformed conditions of modern life any apparent reason for departing from an outworn and mediæval code. Its main contention that Talmudic legalism possesses an authority and a binding force equal to anything pro-
claimed by Moses and the prophets is in view of the history of the origin of the codes entirely fallacious. Still more inimical and disastrous to the true interests of Judaism is the further argument that no competent authority exists in Israel to supplant the old code and set up a new one. Such a proposition, if valid and maintained, would spell the end and doom of Judaism, for every code compiled by human hands is in its very nature perishable. New manners, new customs, new ideals, new economic principles constantly change the conditions of life, and therefore it is that the most perfect religious system or political constitution feels the need from time to time of revision and amendment. For the law of life is change, slow but constant change, not only in the mighty orbs that light up the Universe, but in every pose and fibre of every living organism, whether material or spiritual, that may exist in our own humble but more wonderful world.
Reform on its own side has not been free from grave blunders and unnecessary extravagances. In its inception, it was a natural outcome of the movement for giving full civil and religious liberty to 1 classes of humanity, and the earlier measures of Reform aimed at the esthetic regeneration of the Synagogal liturgy, rather than at the doctrinal readjustment of the content of Judaism. On the part of its pioneers it was an honest endeavor to meet the new situation, but unfortunately, in the course of its immediate development, it groped blindly and stumbled badly. Its expansion was too rapid, and historical and traditional boundaries were too readily over-leaped. There would have been nothing to fear had its development proceeded in an orderly progression and in harmony with the old-time conception of Israel’s destiny. But unfortunately, it fell into the crucible of German philosophic thought, and all that emerged from it was a cold and cheerless ethical monotheism. It lost itself in the morass of metaphysical analysis, and has failed to assume any concrete or definite shape and form. Yet even here a reaction from its philosophical tendencies would restore it to its proper place in the development of Judaism and make it the basis, as its great pioneers and leaders intended it to be of a real and lasting reformation in Israe).