furnishes no parallel to the present condition of affairs. Neither the struggle between the Priestly amd Prophetical parties in kiblical times nor the struggle between Saduceeism and Phariseeism, nor the one between Rabbanism and Karaism can be <ompared to it,for in neither of the former was the integrity of Judaism threatened and its vitality as a homogeneous religious organization, its compact character as a Keneseth Israel, so dangerously impaired as dn the present conflict. For it is not a struggle between secondary principles that is taking place but one that goes to the root of its fundamental elements. Let me here say that I do not recognize either orthodoxy or reform as Judaism in substance and fact. Both are only phases of Judaism which frame for the time being the transtent aspects of Jewish life and worship, and as such are doomed to live their hour and pass away just like other phases of Judaism which once had sway and are now forgotten. And at the present ] think it is worth while submitting both Orthodox and Reform to a little ‘close scrutiny and seek to find out what authority really lies back of the one for its claims to rank as the sole arbiter of all matters affecting Jewish religious life and belief, and the raison d’eter and objects for which the other has been projected.
Modern Orthodoxy may be said to date from about the middle of the Sixteenth Century when Joseph Caro compiled the Schulchan Aruch which in the course of one century became recognized as the authorized code for determining all questions of ritual and practice in Jewish life. In itself it fully exemplified the law of development, for it was an evolutionary product of many previous codes which it superseded. The Mishnah was the first which attempted to codify whatever of authoritative decisions existed on most points of Jewish law. This was followed by the Talmud, which in turn was made the basis for Maimonides System as expounded in the Yad Hachazakah and so on until the author of the Turim made it possible for Caro to compile his great work. For three full centuries it can therefore be said that the Schulchan Aruch has been the leading authority in all Jewish Communities on all questions at issue in every relation of life and so strong a hold has it taken upon the masses that until quite
recently any failure to respect its dicta or to regard it as less than a divinely imposed law, was sufficient to stamp the Dissident as a heretic The Rabbis proclaimed its sanctity as equal to that of the Tora and it formed the instrument of as rigorous a discipline as ever was imposed upon the Jewish people. It thus became the norm and standard of jewish life and conduct. It laid down in minute detail the manner and form in which every ceremony should be conducted, every mitzvah should be performed and every action and occasion in life should be observed. From its inflexible rules no deviation was permitted. Rarely if ever was any exemption allowed even in stress of exceptional circumstances. And Jewry, like one man, bowed down to its decrees. The curious thing about it was that its author never intended the Shulchan Aruch to become the one irrefragable code to be implicitly followea and obeyed by all Israel. He himself had no high opinion of the work, remarking that he had written it for junior students and for those who did not possess a full knowledge of the sources and of the Halachic discussions in the Talmud. How the Shulchan Aruch came to be acknowledged as the supreme authoritative code is explained by the fact that the Rabbis of Poland to a man espousea and adopted it. Perhaps. after all, the hand of Providence can be traced in the history of this digest of Jewish law, for its services in preserving Judaism and giving spiritual consolation and strength to the Jewish people in a time of darkness and depression were undeniably great. The Jew following and obeying its rules became inspired by a certain saintliness of character for he felt strong the consciousness of “walking with God.” And then it somewhat relieved the otherwise dark sombreness of his life. Of course, it shut him out from the sunshine and the vision of the larger life beyond his ghetto walls, but it was perhaps best after all that it did. for if his mind and attention had not been occupied every day, every hour of his life by the strict and punctilious fulfillment of his religious duties, he might never have survived, surrounded as he was by unrelenting hate annd envenomed hostility. But the effect on his personal character must have been of a somewhat ob-