The Maccabaean · Vol. XX, No. 3 · March 1911
114printed page
scan 36 of 54
114
THE MACCABAEAN

the world, and capable of insuring continuity in arbitral jurisprudence."

Further, it is provided that this Court shall meet once a year at The Hague to decide the cases put before it, thus making it, unlike the “Permanent Court,” a really permanent court. It is not unlikely that, when ratified, this court will replace the “Permanent Court of Arbitration” altogether, sooner or later. Whereas the cost of the latter court devolved wholly upon the disputants, the general expenses of a Judicial Arbitration Court (it is provided by Article 31) are to be borne by the Contracting Powers. The purpose of this court is well put by Mr. Choate, one of the American delegates, in introducing the subject for discussion before the first sub-committee of the First Committee: “Let us seek to develop a permanent court which shall hold regular and continuous sessions, which shall consist of the same judges, which shall pay due heed to its own decisions, which shall speak with the authority of the united voice of the nations and gradually build up a system of international law, definite and precise, which shall command the approval and regulate the conduct of the nations.”

The final draft accepted by the Conference follows, it is worth noting, the general principles of the draft submitted by the United States. Our Secretary Knox, furthermore, has been zealous in behalf both of this court, and the International Prize Court, provided by Convention 12. One of the very important, but scarcely heralded, achievements of the Senate in the past session was its ratification of this Convention 12 on February 15. It does not seem probable, considering such things as they usually happen, that the United States would have ratified the Convention unless the government had reason to believe that the other powers were prepared to do likewise. Indeed, it is more than likely that as soon as the powers ratify the Declaration of London (of which a word, in a moment) they will ratify the Convention, too, and directly thereafter this international court will be constituted. As its name signifies, this Court is to have jurisdiction over the capture of prizes in war. By prizes we mean the ships and goods of an enemy or a neutral which are liable to capture by the laws of war. Hitherto, the National

Prize Courts of the captors have determined the rights of the parties in each case. Though bound to administer international law, National Prize Courts, as might have been expected, have been rather partial in their decisions, and grave difficulties have arisen time and time again, especially with neutral powers whose nationals felt themselves aggrieved. Therefore, the institution of a true international court to try all cases of prize on appeal from the national courts is, for fairness to all parties and the prevention of friction between States, of the very highest importance.

Article 7 of the Convention provides: "If the question of law to be decided is covered by a Treaty in force between the belligerent captor and a power which is itself, or whose national is, a party to the proceedings, the court is governed by the provisions of the said treaty.

"In the absence of such provisions, the court shall apply the rules of international law. If no generally recognized rule exists, the court shall give judgment in accordance with the general principles of justice and equity."

It was for the purpose of defining the rules of international law which this court was to administer that Great Britain called a Conference of the naval powers, in December, 1908. This Conference after deliberations extending over two months, drew up the instrument called the Declaration of London. I shall not review this Declaration in its technical details, but merely mention the subjects on which it formulates the law, in order to give even the slightest notion of its scope. Its 71 articles, then, deal with the following subjects: (1) Blockade in time of war; (2) Contraband of war; (3) Unneutral service; (4) Destruction of neutral prizes; (5) Transfer to a neutral flag; (6) Enemy Character; (7) Convoy; (8) Resistance to search; and (9) Compensation. The question of ratifying the Declaration or not is now being keenly debated in England, and Mr. Asquith has postponed the action of his government until after the Imperial Conference meets in the early summer. It seems highly improbable, however, that Great Britain will refuse to ratify the Declaration by which, on the whole, she stands to gain more than to lose. Directly Great Britain