The Maccabaean · Vol. XIX, No. 5 · November 1910
176printed page
scan 24 of 52
176
THE MACCABAEAN

THE YIDDISH PRESS AND PASTOR RUSSELL.

THE MACCABAEAN has been severely and vituperatively criticised in one of the Yiddish newspapers for having published in its last issue a digest of Pastor Russell's Hippodrome sermon, and for having in an editorial refused to follow the methods of the Yiddish press in branding Pastor Russell as a missionary to the Jews.

It is not our intention to point out the peculiar nature of the attack upon Zionist publications by our leading Yiddish newspapers, except to say that the guardians of Israel who themselves have committed the same alleged sin, who have as yet not confessed their own error, are not in a position to censure other publications for doing exactly what they have done. It is strange, however, that while the Hebrew Standard, an orthodox weekly publication, has been giving publicity to Pastor Russell's views, the Yiddish newspapers that have jumped to the conclusion that Pastor Russell is a missionary have not ventured to attack it, although the Standard had published the censured matter weeks after the East Side was sensationalized by the Morgen Journal and the Tageblatt.

THE MACCABAEAN does not propose to become the defender of the methods of Pastor Russell's agents in their endeavor to create a wide publicity for his utterances. THE MACCABAEAN had nothing whatever to do with the, so to speak, "Kosherizing" of Pastor Russell's advertisements. After the Morgen Journal, the Jewish Gazette, the Hebrew Standard, and then Dos Yiddish Volk and Der Yiddisher Kaempfer had opened their columns to the Pastor Russell Lecture Bureau. THE MACCABAEAN entered into a similar arrangement with that Bureau, which it continued for two months.

Our readers, we have no doubt, were perfectly aware of the nature of the transaction. The Pastor Russell Lecture Bureau wished to purchase advertising space in our columns; the management of THE MACCABAEAN sold it to the Bureau, at the regular rates, with the proviso that nothing objectionable appear in its "copy." We have yet to hear from one of our readers who found any thing objectionable in the addresses of Pastor

Russell as they appeared in THE MACCABAEAN.

While the October issue of THE MACCABAEAN was in press, the Morgen Journal, for reasons of its own that will not bear a public discussion, came to the conclusion that Pastor Russell was a missionary to the Jews, and it was followed by the Tageblatt with a vehement attack upon the director of Dos Yiddish Volk, Mr. Joseph Barondess, as if he, and not the Morgen Journal and the Jewish Gazette, were responsible for the approval of the Pastor Russell business. The Tageblatt was at once followed by the New York Kehillah, which branded Pastor Russell as a missionary on the strength of certain passages in a book that had been distributed at the Hippodrome meeting. This book contained references to the Jews, and quoted certain remarks by the notorious Joseph Rabinowitsch, a converted Russian Jew, who recanted before his death. The editor of THE MACCABAEAN has read the passages referred to by the Kehillah and can find absolutely no warrant for basing an indictment of Pastor Russell as a missionary on the passages quoted.

In fact, Pastor Russell's views may be fantastic, but they form a theory that has remarkable coherence. Pastor Russell is a Christian, does not believe in the Trinity, but believes in the coming of the Messiah according to the Hebrew prophets. He believes that for a time the Jewish people have lost the favor of God, but that the day of their deliverance is at hand, when they shall return to the Holy Land, there to establish a model commonwealth. He holds to his own views as to Jesus, but asserts that the Jewish religion is destined to be re-established and become the guidance of the gentile world.

Now, whatever there may be in this view, is of little importance, and the only question at issue is this: Does Pastor Russell hope for the conversion of Jews to Christianity; has he done any thing to convert them; is there anything in what he says that is projected for conversionist purposes? To all these questions there must be a negative answer. He does not hope for the conversion of Jews. There is nothing in his views that tend to convert the Jews. And he has done abso-