The Maccabaean · Vol. XIX, No. 5 · November 1910
175printed page
scan 23 of 52
THE MACCABAEAN
175

EDITORIAL PAGES

Vol. XIX
NOVEMBER. 1910
No. 5

Tue report that the Jewish Colonization Association has decided to abanaon its work in Palestine may be true, and if it is, there is no need for being alarmed about ii. The Ika has all along been an unwilling participant in Palestinian development. Whatever work it has done there has been of a quality that in no way aided in the development of a normal Jewish life. It is characteristic of this association that when Jewish public opinion becomes actually interested in any, given work it has undertaken, it should at once withdraw. The Ika seems to prefer working where there is no public opinion, where the results of its work cannot be gauged, ratheı than in a field where it is subject to the censorship of the Jewish people. It is guided entirely by the code that governs irresponsible bureaucrats.

WHATEVER the reasons may be for the excellent work of the German Hilfsverein in Palestine, it is certain that it will avoid the mistakes made by the French Alliance. The Alliance has been engaged in creating human exports for French consumption. The Hilfsverein will create human material that will be of service to Palestine. And having once accepted that as its policy, the Hilfsverein sees nothing antagonistic to its objects in granting the demands of the Jewish population of the Holy Land. If that population wants Hebrew, it does not insist upon having German as the predominant language in its schools. The Alliance has its seat of office in republican France; the Hilfsverein in monarchical Germany, and yet, the latter seems imbued with a finer sense of democracy than the former.

A FINE moral may be drawn from the life and works of Levinsky (Rebbe Korov), who died in Odessa this month. Here was a man who was a successful merchant, yet his life was spent in the service of Jewish Idealism. No worthy Jewish cause

passed by without his assistance. He devoted his whole soul to the upbuilding of positive Jewish values. As a Hebrew writer he was brilliant, genial, wholesome; but he was a merchant also. So it was with Wizzotsky; so it is with our great Hebrew philosopher, Asher Ginsberg. Where in America do we find such men who, having acquired a competence in the world of commerce, give themselves over to healthy upbuilding Jewish interests? Our successful men in America, with but few exceptions, use the means they acquire to branch out into general philanthropy, and studiously avoid Jewish interests on the ground that they are narrowing. By becoming broad-minded they become shallow. Men like Levinsky may be narrow but they have depth.

The annual meeting of the American Jewish Committee is to be held on November 13. The Jewish public will be interested to hear of the success of its endeavors to solve the Russian passport question. We recall that during the last presidential campaign a great deal of stress was laid by the committee upon a certain letter written by Mr. Taft as to what he hoped to do in that direction. That letter was used by the American Jewish Committee as a campaign document to make votes for the republisan party among 'Jews. Is it possible that the passport question remains in statu quo? It may be that {he Taft administration has made the immigration of Jews to this country particularly difficult in order to be in a position to deal with the vexatious problem o? the passport. If the American Jewish Committee is solely concerned in Jewish interests, it seems about time for it to abandon the republican party to its fate and to shift over to the democratic party. But that would probably be politics, and the American Jewish Committee bars polit!cs altogether.