Zionistic state is to be no different from this why should we be interested in it?
The reply has been that all ready made substitutes for the state as we know it are utopian, and especially the socialistic commonwealth—the sort of state, of course, which the critics above referred to have in mind. But whether this reply is valid or not as against the socialists, it has no force against the co-operative agricultural community as proposed by Dr. Oppenheimer. Here we have in the germ a different social organization from that prevailing around us, and yet one that has been abundantly tested and found sound, one that holds within itself the new spirit, the spirit of democratic co-operation and yet loses not a particle of individualistic energy and incentive.
The practicability of co-operative agricultural communities may be most impressivelv brought to mind by citing two or three examples of successful experiments. The first is only partly co-operative, the land is owned in common—the single-tax ı3 applied. This association is at Fairhope on the east shore of Mobile Bay in Alabama. It now owns 1600 acres of land; has a population between five and seven hundred; its dwellings have been more than doubled iu six years. It has been in existence I5 years and the village has made more rapid progress than any other place on the eastern shore of Mobile Bay. The Amana and Shaker communities are communistic bue nevertheless, from an economic point of view, highly successful. The Amana societies, which do not prohibit marriage, number seventeen or eighteen hundred members living in seven villages about the center of Iowa. The communistic feature of these societies is undesirable and the fact that they have succeeded in spite of it shows the great advantage of co-operation. A great illustration of tbe power of agri-
culturial co-operation was offered over a century ago in County Clare, Ireland at Raharine. The Irish peasants in this locality before the experiment was tried were in the most miserable condition of poverty and devoted much of their time to criminal acts against the owner of their land. It was the latter who inaugurated the experiment. He gave each of his tenants a lease on a parcel of land and formed them into a co-operative association. The undertaking was on a strictly business basis. In a short time those Irish peasents were transformed from a band of starving criminals to a prosperous community of self-respecting and energetic farmers. The change seemed miraculous. Unfortunately the laws of the country at that time did not provide for such an arrangement as this landlord had made with his tenants and on his death the land was taken away from the farmers and they relapsed to their former conditions. The value of the lesson in co-operation however remains. A great many more examples could be cited if space permitted.
Zionism does not pledge itself to any utopian ideal in croosing the co-operative method of developing land bought with the resources of the National Fund. It selectsthe most practical plan. The expectation of success need not be directed to the remote future. Results will come immediately; that is, as soon as from any other agricultural undertaking. At the same time, remote results may be expected also and those engaging in this enterprise may have the consciousness that whatever the immediate benefits flowing therefrom may be, they are setting on foot a movement that has in it the promise of a great improvement over the prevailing social and industrial organizations in Europe and America.
