Jewish colonies. Every man will stand upon his own feet and make as much as he can. If he does work for the community he will receive pay according to the amount of his labor. If he wishes, he may work outside the community. He has perfect liberty to do with his labor as he pleases. The advantages of co-operation are positive, obvious and there for him to avail himself of. For the rest, whether he erow fat or starve is his own look onıt.
The success of a community based upon agricultural association as Dr. Oppenheimer sketches it is practically sure. Confidence in such an undertaking is supported by the history of former experiments as well as by analysis of the proposed institution. It would not be a closed community. The accession of industrial workers would be to the interest of ıhose engaged in agricultural work, for this would create a market close at hand for many agricultural products. Since the increase in population could not cause a rise in the value of land, the land being, as has been said, community property, there would be no artificial obstacles to the natural development of the community, and the outcome would be a happy combination of town and country to the mutual advantage of both elements.
Co-operation in our community need not, of course, stop with the agricultural workers. The agriculturists themselves would naturally combine in associations for the working up of their products into forms of higher value, associations for fruit drying and packing, for example. The industrial workers might form associations beneficial to themselves. But the agricultural association would be the basic one by virtue of the communal ownership of the land.
Is the plan practicable for Zionists in Palestine? If it is practicable at all for Zionists to hold land in Palestine this seems by far the most reasonable way of holding it. Every colonist instead of fighting single-handed would have the immense advantage of association with other colonists. Instead of having only his own in-
significant capital to work with he would have the capital of the association. Instead of fighting for his own head alone, he would be fighting for all and receiving the support and encouragement of the others. At the same time none of the incentive for personal endeavor would be his incentive for all he earned would be his.
The Zionist Congress did well to endorse Dr. Oppenheimer’s plan. Zionism appeals in various ways to those who are attracted by it. Perhaps the prevailing appeal is to what may be called historical sentimentalısm: Let us have again what we once had, a state of our own; bring back the golden age of Jewish patriotism and independence; let us stand again a nation among nations. This sentiment has already accomplished much. It is not to be undervalued either in efficiency or sincerity. But there are many hard heads even among Jews who are aware that nature (or, in other words the process of history) is no respecter of sentiment as such. Regret and longing have, no doubt, their place in the economy of the soul, but you cannot build the future on them. And so, many who are interested in the Zionist ideal demand that it shall be based firmly on present conditions and answer present problems.
Grown men know that you cannot achieve ends by wishing for them. You must think of the means. You may send a few million Jews into Palestine fervently believing that they will establish a just and happy state, but it is possible that unless the right measures are adopted to secure such a state, the outcome may be something to be ashamed rather than proud of. What particular glory will it be, some Zionists have been saying, to reproduce in Palestine the social conditions of Europe and America; to have struggles between capital and labor; to have sweatshops; to have men out of employment and men working for just enough to live on, to have millionaires and vagrants; to have corruption in politics and the grinding of the people between the upper and nether millstone of the politicians and the corporations? If the
