The Maccabaean · Vol. XVIII, No. 2 · February 1910
66printed page
scan 30 of 52
66
THE MACCABAEAN

THE NEW DISPERSION.

It is error to ascribe consistency to the various attempts made by our philanthropic leaders to administer the communal affairs of our people in the United States. The policy changes with the circumstances. Witness, for instance, the variety of tactics employed by them in combatting the restriction of immigration. When Mr. Wolf and Judge Mack testify before the Commission on Immigration, they argue that it would not be wise to give publicity to the actual number of Jews coming into this country, for our enemies would at once distort the facts and thus incite the American legislator to take steps to put an end to Jewish immigration. Consequently, they argue, the less said of Jews, the better. What they meant was: Avoid public discussion of the immigration problem; say nothing, for if you do, what you say will be wrongly used against us.

That was Mr. Schiff’s views, probably, when he urged an unwilling audience on the East Side to rise in their seats, and thus pay their “respects” to Commissioner ‚Williams. They rose in the seats, not because they felt that an honor of this sort was due the cruel executive oflicer, who enforces kis interpretation of law upon helpless immigrants, but because they felt that Mr. Schiff’s policy demanded respect to an oflicer of the law, who must be shown, no matter what the actual conditions were, that the Jews acquiesce in the administration of the law. This has been done before. Our friends, the pEil- anthropic leaders, have always hobnobbed with Commissioners of Immigration, even when they were well known to be prejudiced against Jews, for they thought that more could be gained by flattery and acquiescence than by open protest.

What, then, does Mr. Schiff mean, when he publicly admits that the congestion of Jews in the large cities is a menace, and their dispersion an urgent necessity? Has he abandoned the old policy? Has he discovered that the Jewish problem can be

solved by frank, democratic and less ingenuous methods?

That is not possible, for the incident related of Mr. Williams’ visit to the East Side occurred about the same time that he made his appeal to tke East Side to relieve the congestion by scattering. Mr. Schiff is not yet a firm believer in a republican treatment of Jewish problems. He still maintains that the old policy must be adhered to. His plea for scattering was merely an outbreak of the naturally sincere man, who, although he wears the mantle of diplomacy, when he sees the evil results of tke large enforced immigration of his “co-religionists,” is compelled to speak up, in natural fashion, proposing a natural and obvious solution of the prob- leın.

Nevertheless, the fat is in the fire. In spite of the many attempts to withhold from the American public, the true state of affairs—which in our opinion, never would have been inimical to Jewish interests—in spite of the maintainance at Washington by the amiable Mr. Wolf, of the fiction that the Jews are not Jews, but Germans, Frenchmen, Russians, etc., of the unnecessary protests of patriotism, which, with so many, have seemed the essential requirement of the situation: the restrictionists will use Mr. Schiff’s latest speech advising the scattering of the Jews with more effect than our friends have ever used the other, formal, diplomatic evasions of the truth.

Although we do not approve of the position taken by our confused philanthropic leaders, we regret exceedingly the utterances of Mr. Schiff, on the points mentioned. The problem is but half put when he admits that congestion is an evil. The Jewish problem does not hinge on congestion. It arises both out of congestion and out of dispersion, but more so out of dispersion. Mr. Schiff's plan of scattering the Jews to the south and west may benefit Jews temporarily, but the Jewish people will lose thereby. It will lose the energy exerted by the dispersed to