EDITORIALS
THE RUSSIAN ZIONISTS.
THE reported secession of the Russian Zionists from the Congress recently held in Hamburg, was, as we learn from later reports, an unwarranted deduction from the sharp division of opinion, which existed in the Congress on the personalities and policies of the central executive committee. There was no issue of principle involved.
The administration, represented by David Wolffsohn, received tke endorsement of a substantial majority of the delegates. It cannot be said that Wolffsohn opposes the demands of the Russian delegates for practical work in Palestine; he favors the development of Jewish strength in the Holy Land with as muck intensity and zeal as does any ‚Russian Zionist, but he is unwilling to lend the entire support of the executive committee, to the plans .evolved by the Russians for an individual development in Palestine; he believes that the national interests are specifically the concern of his committee; tkat the individual enterprises may rely upon the individual agencies, working with the moral sanction of the organization, for their initiation.
Against this policy the Russian Zionists launched their criticism. That criticism mistook caution and sagacity for opposition. It was based on ill-advised and thoughtless zeal, which had not taken account of practical experience. Eagerness and enthusiasm lent wings to the unseemly attacks upon Wolffsohn, but the sober sense of the critics will soon bring them to realize that while enthusiasm and eagerness are good things, they must not prevail over common sense and experience, no matter how slow the latter may be in the realization of the Zionist hope.
The Zionist movement aims to arouse the national consciousness of the Jewish
people in order that they may go up to Mount Zion, and there create anew tke Jewish national home. In order to stimulate that going and that building, the Zionist movement aims also to establish in Palestine the conditions precedent to such an exodus; it will build up the national skeleton around which the Jewish people, inspired by their ideal, shall adkere. It is for the individual to become the citizen, it is for the movement to create the state. Whatever is in the nature of statecraft, state enterprises, of a national scope, comes within the province of the central organization. When the Russian Zionists confuse this policy by demanding that the entire strength: of the Zionist organization, and of its financial institutions, shall be thrown into the work of individual colonization, they are, consciously or unconsciously, threatening the very existence of the national ideal of our movement.
They are undermining the power of the national ideal. They are sacrificing the future of the Jewish nation, for the sake of immediate gains, that are as yet not safeguarded, and that may, at any moment, by their failure, discredit the movement. They are abandoning the hard-won position of the Zionist movement for a petty and uncontrolled conquest of Palestine. They are willing to let the return of the Jews into Palestine become an indiscriminate, unregulated, unsystematic, insecure movement. They are a witness, moreover, of their own feebleness of imagination, when they think that the problem of rebuilding a Jewish nation can be accomplished solely by appeals for an individual movement into the national territory.
The Russian Zionists are creatures of impulse, poetic fervor, sentimentalism and local circumstances. It is the hope of every Zionist that those who adopt the alleged “practical” policy may come to realize that theirs is the way of confusion and must end in a hopeless chaos in Jewish national life, if they persist in their undisciplined enthusiasm.