The Maccabaean · Vol. XVIII, No. 1 · January 1910
22printed page
scan 22 of 52
Facsimile · scan 22 of 52
Scan of p. 22
Text · transcribed from the scan

cause of uncertain governmental conditions. There is that difference as compared with other immigration. Now, ought we to disregard the uniform practice of our Bureau of Immigration, possibly since 1820, ought we to disregard Mr. Hayes's very excellent note in relation to Roumania, ought we to disregard all the correspondence of our Secretaries of State for years past with the Russian Government as to passports, in no one of which instances has the correspondence or the figures related to the Jewish religion, but to the Jewish people as an entirety; ought we to throw away all that because of a contention as to which Jews, using now the term from a religious standpoint, are themselves divided!

Mr. Wolf. The question between Russia and this Government on the passport matter is on the non-recognition of a passport in the hands of one who, while being a Jew in faith, is an American citizen; and our contention is that the Government of Russia had no right to discriminate against any American citizen, which they did do and which they do now.

Rep. Bennet. We called their attention specifically to the fact that the only American citizens against which they discriminated are those whom they call Jews.

Mr. Wolf. People of Jewish faith, and as already indicated, Russia does not recognize Jews as citizens.

Rep. Bennet. Not necessarily. They ask at the embassy, "Is this citizen a Jew by birth," not faith, and they refuse a passport to a man who is an apostate from the Jewish religion, if he is of Jewish birth. Ought we to throw away all that for which we have contended because of something that is urged by a divided sentiment?

Mr. Wolf. Are we going to be regulated in regard to our domestic affairs by any condition that exists in Russia or by any legislation that exists in Russia?

Rep. Bennet. Not at all.

Mr. Wolf. Not at all.

Rep. Eennet. But we must have a united American contention, and our contention

in relation to Russia always has been that every American citizen is entitled to all the rights that every other American citizen is entitled to.

Mr. Wolf. Certainly. Therefore the word "Jew" as used in the correspondence has nothing to do with the rights guaranteed to every citizen.

Rep. Bennet. Exactly. We object to any and every discrimination against a Jew by birth as well as against a Jew by religion.

Mr. Wolf. Exactly.

Rep. Bennet. Are we for any reason to be driven from ground where we can contend that a man who is a Jew by birth loses no rights if he ceases to be a Jew by religion?

Mr. Wolf. How can he lose any right by simply being classified as a Russian? What the man's religion may be does not concern either party.

Rep. Bennet. No.

Mr. Wolf. That is all we claim. Let the record show that so many Russians are coming here, so many Germans, so many Englishmen or Frenchmen, or whatever nationality they may be. The Jew in Russia ——

Senator Lodge. How are you going to define the nationalities? We must make it the same for everybody. Are you going to classify a Hungarian as an Austrian?

Mr. Wolf. The Hungarians, as far as their allegiance is concerned under present conditions, are undoubtedly Austrians. They are Hungarians, of course. Hungary is a separate and distinct kingdom.

Senator Lodge. How would you classify the Croatians, the Galicians, according to the race they represent in Austria. We classify them according to their race, not according to their allegiance, or religion.

Mr. Wolf. I am aware of that.

Senator Lodge. The Irish are a perfect illustration of that. They are not classi-