The Maccabaean · Vol. XVIII, No. 1 · January 1910
21printed page
scan 21 of 52
Facsimile · scan 21 of 52
Scan of p. 21
Text · transcribed from the scan

Mr. Wolf. That may be.

. Senator Lodge. I have never supposed for one moment, and I do not now suppose, that the Jews who are put down in the immigration returns as such are classified according to religion.

Mr. Wolf. You classify them, under the supposition, as I understand —

Senator Lodge. On the supposition that it is a race.

Mr. Wolf. That the Jewish people constitute a race as the English are a race, as the Germans are a race, and so forth.

Senator Lodge. Yes; as the Poles are a race, though they have no country and no nationality; as the Irish are a race, althey have no nationality and no country.

Mr. Wolf. I understand, but how much there is in that information I do not know, that the opposition to classifying these people as immigrants from Russia is owing to the protest made by the Russian authorities, we do not wish it understood that so many Russian subjects are emigrating to the United States.

Senator Lodge. I never heard of that.

The Chairman. Nor have I.

Mr. Wolf. That has been stated.

Senator Lodge. I do not imagine that has anything to do with it. It never occurred to me until I heard you were coming here that the classification as made by the Immigration authorities had anything to do with religion. I supposed it was a race classification. It is important, very important, to get the race classification as nearly as we can.

Mr. Wolf. Yes.

Senator Lodge. As you all know there are what are called scientific races; that is, the races which are defined by physical peculiarities; the great divisions, like the Mongol, the Negro, the North American Indian, the Aryan, the Semitic. Those are what are called the scientific races, where the difference in the skulls and so on has all been retained. Of course, in Europe there has been a great mixture of races and the scientific divisions have

largely disappeared. But there are peoples which have been formed gradually, as the English, the German, in which there is a great mixture of blood, but which are historically racial, just as the Poles are historically a race. They may not be scientifically a race, because there is a considerable admixture of blood. But the classification made by the Immigration Bureau is on the basis of historic races in contradistinction to the broad scientific divisions which would be of no value whatever in making returns. I have always supposed that this classification was made exactly as they classify the Irish and the Pole, as the Syrian and the Armenian. It would be an absurdity to classify the Syrians and the Armenians as Turks. They are subjects of the Sultan of Turkey, of course; they are Turks politically.

Mr. Wolf. You are aware that the Census Bureau some time ago attempted to classify in the same manner, and it was prohibited from doing so.

Senator Lodge. The word "race" was stricken out of the census report. I think it was a great mistake. It makes the returns almost valueless.

Mr. Wolf. I can simply repeat what I have said, that I am voicing the opinions of those whom I represent —the Union of American Hebrew Congregations and the Order B'nai B'rith. They are opposed to the classification as made in the last few years and as contemplated, so far as I am informed, in the report of the Commission. Of course, no one can foreshadow what the report will be. There are other questions that I desire to bring to the attention of the Commission, if you desire to hear me.

Rep. Bennet. Before going into any matter I should like to ask one question. I think there is a distinction between the immigration of Jewish people from Russia and Roumania and of Armenians from all parts of the Turkish Empire and all other immigration, because as to them there is the element of flight; they come over largely because of oppression and be-