The Maccabaean · Vol. XVII, No. 6 · December 1909
207printed page
scan 25 of 52
THE MACCALAEAN
207

in my life; I made it one of my principles to write simply and without a trace of rancor. As we conversed, the servant brought in a large dish of barley soup and a loaf of bread. Shorr invited me to partake of the repast, which I did with avidity. He sat down near me and continued the conversation.

He said that he did not eat meat. For breakfast, early in the morning, he partook of a glass of milk and then went out for a long walk in the woods, defying the heat in the summer and the cold in winter. It seemed to him that walking, motion, was a good intellectual stimulant. He confessed that when he was younger he wrote his best works while walking. The Hungarian Jewish poet, Joseph Kish, told him that walking inspired to great production, which he could not do at home.

Schorr then passed on to several topics; finally we came to the subject of writing Jewish history in accordance with the Talmud.

"Herzl," he said to me, "never take the Hagadah as the mine from which you will dig out treasures to enrich our great history. The Haggadist is an individual who manufactured those legends, most of which are unreliable as historical material. The Halacha is the real source that will provide us with the material for a history of our people. The law was evolved out of certain conditions, in which the nation found itself placed. For instance, the law prohibiting the drinking of Roman wine, as well as drinking with Romans; what was behind that peculiar law? It was made to meet a national condition. They

were planning a revolt then, against the Romans, and in order to make impossible any treason, they barred all Jews from drinking with the enemy."

For ten days I fed my mind with Schorr's spiritual conversation and my stomach with his ever welcome barley soup. I learned those nights more than I could have learned in an entire course at a seminary.

When I said good-bye to him, he gave me a letter to his friend Nachman Krock- mal, who had fought with him shoulder to shoulder against the fanatics. I told Schorr that I was grateful to him for his attention, but I wanted to recommend myself by my own merits. He explained that his intention was merely to ask Krochmal to use his influence at Lemberg to have my poems published, and introduce me to the literary world. I was greatly flattered at his attention to a poor boy like me, and went away, feeling everlastingly grateful to him.

In my life's trip, I found three learned men who never discouraged an obscure talent. They were Schorr, Krochmal and Judge Mayer Sulzberger. When an undiscovered genius comes before an editor, he is usually killed with kindness. It was my good fortune that I was not buried in editorial sanctums.

When I left Schorr, I took with me my two orphan brothers and brought them home to my mother. It is needless to say that this was one of my first serious responsibilities; I discharged it like a poet. That is, I did not get my brothers into the asylum at Brody.