The Maccabaean · Vol. XVII, No. 5 · November 1909
153printed page
scan 3 of 52
Facsimile · scan 3 of 52
Scan of p. 153
Text · transcribed from the scan

self a Zionist; it is implicit in my activity as a Jew; but there is nothing in my Zionism which impels me to subscribe to political schemes for emigrating refugees from Russia or to make shift with a fragile substitute for the hope which has sustained my people since the Temple was destroyed. Let me quote Isaiah for a moment—Isaiah, the first and greatest, the most eloquent and most spiritual of Zionists, whose burning pride in his own race and whose invincible belief in its destiny combine in an impassioned appeal to which no true Jew can be deaf. "The sons of them that afflicted thee shall come bending unto thee, and all they that despise thee shall bow themselves down at the soles of thy feet; and they shall call thee, The City of the Lord, the Zion of the Holy One of Israel." "I will bring thy seed from the East, and gather thee from the West. I will say to the North, give up, and to the South, keep not back. Bring my sons from far, and my daughters from the ends of the earth; everyone that is called by my name. For I have created him for my glory, I have formed him, yea, I have made him."

What is there of this prophetic confidence, of this stubborn and steadfast faith, in the scheme of Dr. Herzl or the dream of Mr. Zangwill? “The departure of the Jews,” says the one, “will involve no economic disturbances, no crises, no persecutions; in fact, the countries they abandon will revive to a new period of prosperity. There will be an inner migration of Christian citizens into the positions evacuated by Jews”—truly a terrible travesty of the ideal in which kings were to come to our light, and queens were to be our nursing-mothers. And as to the Zionism of Mr. Zangwill, “Palestine,” he says, was “but an afterthought” (I am quoting from the “Dreamers of the Ghetto”). “Yet, since there is this longing for Palestine, let us make capital of it—capital that will return its safe percentage.”

I have read a fair amount of Jewish literature, and I venture to assert that not

Heine himself, in his bitterest and most disillusioned mood, ever touched with more savage satire a high and an inspiring ideal. Zion is to "return a safe percentage." All the hope, and the patience, and the waiting, all the suffering, and the agony, and the martyrdom, all the inspired belief in an end transcending the unfulfilled prayers and the incomplete longings of the ages, is to be sacrificed to the temporary advantage of utilizing the name Zion on the prospectus of a company formed for colonizing some out-of-the-way soil, where Jews may lay down their burden, and abandon their privilege, and forget Jerusalem. Surely, to quote Isaiah again, "The bed is shorter than that a man can stretch himself on it; and the covering narrower than he can wrap himself in it." Zionism demands an ampler air. Zionism—the symbol of emancipation—the promise of redemption—the salvation of the world—will not permanently acquiesce in so humiliating a defeat, nor adopt so foreshortened a standard in lieu of its age-long aim.

I need not elaborate that aim. I was a Zionist before Dr. Herzl, before I met him in Vienna in the year 1896, when Der Judenstaat was still untranslated, and had still to do its work in altering the acceptance of the term Zionist in this country. If I would keep my name to-day, I may, perhaps, borrow a term from a sphere in which I am particularly interested, and describe myself now as a pre-Raphaelite Zionist, as a Zionist who reverts in principle to a simpler and a more direct symbolism, and who is content to depend for his effects on less sophisticated forms of art. I believe in an ultimate Zion, not geographically fixed, nor dated in time, but gradually to be approached by the fulfilment of our mission in the countries in which we are dispersed.

This scheme is worth elaborating, for, at the trivial risk of seeming to utter a paradox, I hold that Zionists of the type, say, of Mr. Israel Zangwill, are doing their utmost to rob us of Zion. They display a want of imagination, an imper-