The Maccabaean · Vol. XVII, No. 5 · November 1909
152printed page
scan 2 of 52
Facsimile · scan 2 of 52
Scan of p. 152
Text · transcribed from the scan

structure of the spiritual imagination, which becomes more tangible and visible when the shadows of experience lose their shapes. So I speak of the Zion at which I aim, distant and reluctant though it be, and though my efforts to restore it are confined to the spiritual sphere. My faith transcends the disappointments of false prophets and criers for a sign. As well ask for proofs of immortality convincingly to an intellect of five senses, as well accept table-rappings and chain-clankings as an instalment of divine illumination, as cross religion with politics and contaminate Zion with finance.

The Zion of Jewish idealism, the Zion at which I aim, I conceive as universal and remote. There are certain conditions to be fulfilled, conditions not to be realized in our time, though never excluded from our control, before the local is merged in the universal and the remote draws near. What is the destiny of Israel? There are those, I read, who would be contented with a station by the way, who would find in Turkey, or Argentina, or in that blessed name, Mesopotamia, a satisfactory solution for the destiny of the race. They would give the so-called nation a destination, and let the destiny of the race make shift. I read of these opinions in the Jewish press, in the records of long and stormy meetings of various nationalist propagandists, who have been at work for a good many years—who have constitutions and funds and talkers, but who, as far as I am aware, have as yet done little save to confuse the ideal conception of Zion with cross-bred schemes of Zionism.

I am very deeply in sympathy with the brave and ardent men and women who spend laborious days in trying to alleviate the sufferings of persecuted Jews in Russia, Roumania, and other countries. I would hardly be necessary to state this proposition, which as a mere profession of opinion, is the barest statement of common humanity, and has not the least claim to applause, if it were not that political Zionists (who are subject, like other

politicians, to the degrading influences of politics), try so frequently to represent all such expressions of opinion as valueless outside their fold.

“How can you sympathize with the persecuted if you will not adopt our remedy for relief?” is the question they constantly ask; and even if some of them admit that there is a more ideal Zionism than their own, they affect to hold the expedient creed that in this exceptional instance— such instances are always exceptional—the end justifies the means, and that for the sake of his brethren’s wrongs, the Jew whose sympathy is to count, must consent to cramp his Zionism into the Procrustes-bed of a contemporary Jewish settlement. No passing-cry is more contemptible. I wholly deny to Zionists who have joined associations or leagues of that denomination, a monopoly of sympathy with foreign Jews who are suffering persecution for race or creed; and I hold it to be a dangerous sign of cleavage in Jewish ranks with all its deplorable consequences in party opinion and party morality, when the adherents of a special policy claim to be the sole repositories of common virtues and of practical aid.

I may be asked at this point, in condemning the Zionistic scheme of redemption, to suggest an alternative means of accomplishing this aim. I am not prepared with an alternative. The critic ex hypothesi is never Chancellor of the Exchequer, nor should I in any case feel called upon to dictate the course of history. But apart from my natural modesty, I have yet to learn that redemption by modern schemes of Zionism is going to redeem any appreciable portion of the misery that exists. I have yet to measure its success by the practical tests on which it prides itself, and above all—very far above all—I have yet to satisfy my conscience—the Jewish conscience which I inherit and transmit—that Zion is the symbol of no larger hope than that of relief from local persecution.

So, if the admission be required, I give it freely and unashamed: I still call my-