last 100 years. It has succeeded in detaching many of them from Judaism, but it has failed to avert anti-Semitism. The attempt to make young English Jews entirely English in thought, and to identify them entirely with the English people, has already succeeded in weakening English Judaism; by cutting at the roots of Jewish idealism and impairing the hold of the religion, with all that it means for the strengthening of moral character and the suppression of material aims, it may even foster anti-Semitism in this country.
The second letter was written by Mr. Ernest Lesser, who said:
TO THE EDITOR OF THE "JEWISH CHRONICLE."
SIR,—With all deference to the galaxy of intellect and intelligence represented by the signatories of the letter under the above heading in your last issue, I venture to submit that not only does their letter fail to bring out clearly the really vital point at issue, but that it gives utterance to a broad proposition to which many people, in sympathy with the object of the letter, will feel quite unable to subscribe. The difficulty in which I find myself is that while totally disappointing of Zionist propaganda at the Universities. I cannot see my way clear to differ from Mr. Bentwich as regards the statement in his interview to which the signatories of the letter mainly take exception. It seems to me that, so long as Jews are determined to conserve their racial purity by refusing to intermarry with the natives of the various countries in which they elect to settle, Mr. Bentwich is perfectly justified in saying of English Jews that "they cannot be as entirely English in thought as the man who is born of English parents and descended from ancestors who have mingled their blood with other Englishmen for generations." They may, as the result of their marvellous acquisitive and imitative powers, become quasi—or almost English in thought, especially if they throw off all allegiance to their faith. But, so long as they steadfastly refuse to
termarry, they can never expect to become more than an exceedingly good imitation of the indigenous Englishman. It is a mere quibble to lay stress on the fact that they are complete Englishmen in the eyes of the law, and that they can, and do, make excellent English citizens. The really important fact to note is that, outside the realm of the law, they are not, in fact, Englishmen, albeit admirable counterfeits. What there is to be distressed at in the recognition of such a fact I utterly fail to appreciate. We cannot, surely, expect to have it both ways—to become complete Englishmen while remaining loyal and steadfast, i.e., complete Jews.
I have no wish unduly to trespass on your space by enlarging on the impossibility of Jews becoming complete Englishmen so long as they insist on maintaining their racial purity. I would only ask those of a contrary opinion to bear in mind that we have here to do with a Semitic race in juxtaposition with an Aryan race. In other words, the gulf to be bridged is far wider than that obtaining between two European stocks. The differences of character, temperament and mental attitude towards things are far more profound, and nothing short of race fusion can be expected to eliminate them.
It seems to me that the signatories of the letter should rather have based their protest upon the ground that the movement with which Mr. Bentwich is associated is inconsistent and at variance with the ordinary ideals of English citizenship. It is unjustifiable for men to claim all the rights and privileges of English citizenship, unless they can, whole-heartedly and unreservedly, take up all the recognized burdens and duties attaching to such citizenship. The question we have, therefore, to ask ourselves, is whether English Zionists can, whole-heartedly and without any reservation, take up all these burdens and duties. In my humble opinion the answer to this question must be in the negative. In matters of citizenship a man cannot serve two masters. Circumstances
