the establishment of the Kingdom of God on earth—all these are the common ideals and the common ideas that permeate the whole Jewish literature, extending over nearly 4,000 years." Do the protestors repudiate these ideals and ideas? If so, I do not hesitate to say that their views encourage disloyalty to Judaism, and would make the young generation no better Englishmen for it. Do they accept these ideals and ideas? Then, how can they claim to be entirely English in thought?
The protestors regard the opinions I have set forth as dangerous to Jewish students, because (a) they must tend to alienate them from other Englishmen; (b) they demolish the structure of the arguments by which the Act for the removal of Jewish disabilities was supported; (c) they are likely to arouse suspicion, particularly in the working classes, as to the measure of patriotism of English Jews. In reply to these charges (a) I fail to see why respect and regard for their own history and literature should tend to alienate Jews from other Englishmen any more than it tends to alienate Scotchmen or Irishmen from the rest of the British people; (b) I do not know that there is any divine infallibility about the arguments of Lord Macaulay, or that we are pledged by what some of our predecessors may have said fifty years ago (even supposing that it was inconsistent with our attitude to-day), any more than we are pledged to uphold the idea that the settlement of Jews in England will help to bring about the millennium, though this idea, I understand, was one of the reasons advanced for our readmission in the time of Cromwell; (c) I do not believe that loyalty to our historic ideals will engender suspicion as to our patriotism among the thinking members of the working or any other classes; and as to the rest, they will in any case regard the Jew as a foreigner and an alien, whatever he may do or give up.
The fears raised by the protestors are, I think, shadowy and baseless; but, on the
other hand, the views which they appear to recommend, namely, that English Jews should endeavor to become entirely English in thought and renounce every separate aspiration, interest and zeal, seem to be dangerous for "the rising generation of educated Jews," because they must tend to alienate English from other Jews; they demolish the historic consciousness, which is one of the great bonds of our religion, and they aid that process of disintegration which ends either in direct apostasy or in religious indifference and gradual absorption in the majority. This attitude seems to illustrate the statement of Spinoza that the so-called emancipation of the Jews must inevitably lead to the extinction of Judaism wherever the process is extended beyond the political to the social sphere.
Finally, the protestors are concerned because they do not believe that "it is logical for persons to claim rights and duties as English citizens when they assert that they cannot completely identify themselves with the English nation and cannot be entirely English in thought." At the risk of repetition I say that the complete carrying out of all the obligations and privileges of English citizenship does not require the Jews to merge their separate culture and historic ideals which make them, in some respects, different in thought. Good citizenship is a matter not of thought, but of action; and it is not a sign of patriotism to sink individuality. A Jewish member of Parliament could not speak without incurring derision of "our ancestors who fought against the Spanish Armada or against the French at Waterloo," but he could speak with pride of our ancestors who were the moral teachers of the world. Yet even if there were any discrepancy, the need is surely greater to preserve Judaism in England than to protect English Jews from possible anti-Semitic attacks. The attempt to make the Jews of France and Germany entirely French and German in thought, and to identify them entirely with the French and German nations, has been tried in the
