The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 4 · April 1909
124printed page
scan 8 of 52
124
THE MACCABAEAN

horted the Judean remnants to hold fast to their commonwealth. It was Ezekiel who was so wrapped up in the hope of return that he elaborated the constitution of the future land and the plans of the future temple with a precision and wealth of detail which might excite the envy of professional statesmen and architects. It was the Great Unknown Prophet, the inspired champion of the great Jewish ideal to which the Reform Jews gave the Christian name of a Jewish Mission, who, with burning enthusiasm and thrilling tenderness, exhorted and implored the exiles to comfort the afflicted widow of Zion. It was Haggai, Zachariah and Malachi, the last prophets of our people, who devoted all their energy and eloquence to the establishment and strengthening of the commonwealth. Surely, were it to be admitted that the only "true followers" of the prophets of Israel are to be found among Reform Jews (compare p. 226), were the prophets to them more than an empty phrase and a convenient subterfuge from the burdens of the Law, then they ought to be among the foremost to work for "the possession of autonomous government" and for the realization of the prophetic ideal that "the Law shall go forth from Zion and the word of the Lord from Jerusalem."

We have confined ourselves to two passages in Rabbi Morgenstern's paper, because of their tendency to discredit a great Jewish movement of the present day, a tendency which was unmistakably confirmed by the "philistine-like outburst" (p. 239) of applause from his hearers and by the protests of two of his colleagues. But this does not imply that the rest of the paper stands on a higher level. As a matter of fact, it is only an immature rehash of all that is most offensive to Jewish senti-

ment and Jewish dignity in “modern scientific research,” and its only originality consists in the uncharitable and irreverent tone which is unusual even among the “high” and “highest” critics. As far as the contents of the paper are concerned, they show our utter submissiveness and servility in the face of non-Jewish opinion. As for the form, it is a matter of taste and—de gustibus non est disputandum. But perhaps it is not inopportune to recall the words of one who can hardly be accused of orthodoxy or connivance to conservative tendencies. It is Friedrich Nietzsche, the great revolutionizer of all standards and values, who penned the following words, discourteous, to be sure, but truthful, on the subject under discussion (Jen- seits von Gui und Boese No. 263): “The manner in which on the whole the reverence for the Bible has been maintained in Europe is perhaps the finest bit of discipline and refinement which Europe owes to Christianity: such books of depth and ultimate significance need for their protection an external tyranny of authority in order to gain those thousands of years of permanence which it is necessary to draw from them and to divine their last meaning. Much is gained when the big crowd (the Shallow and Quick-bowelled of all sorts) are at last trained to feel that they have no right to finger everything; that there are sacred experiences before which they have to put off their shoes and hold back their filthy hands,—it is, as it were, their highest elevation to humanity. As for the so-called educated, the adepts of ‘modern ideas,’ nothing is perhaps more disgusting than their lack of shame, their convenient impudence of eye and hand with which they touch, lick and finger everything.” --From The American Hebrew, signed I.F.

--From The American Hebrew, signed I.F.