where Israel dwelt nor the possession of autonomous government.”
This supposition that our ancestors at the time of the Babylonian captivity were devoid of that natural sentiment towards their native land which is to be found even among savages is a gross fallacy, not to use, with our hot-tempered ex-President, a shorter and uglier word. Seldom have facts of history been so unscrupulously distorted, as it done here to suit a shallow, flimsy theory. When the Judeans were first led captive to Babylon under Jehoiakin (in 597), they numbered 8,000 (II Kings 24, 16), or 10,000 (ibidem verse 14. Compare Stade in Zeitschrift fuer alttes- tamentliche Wissenschaft iv, 271). The number of exiles in the second deportation (in 586) cannot be determined with certainty. According to Stade, it was smaller than the first. According to others (see Buhl, die sociale Verhältnisse der Israeliten p. 53), it was “considerably larger.” (compare also, if Rabbi Morgenstern will pardon me for quoting a Jewish authority, Graetz’ History, German Edition, volume II, second half p. 377 ff.). To be perfectly fair, let us adopt the latter view and assume that the second deportation was three times larger than the first. Let us further suppose that in the course of the half century of the Babylonian captivity the Jewish population of Babylon doubled its numbers,—truly, a fair percentage of natural increase. How many Jews were then in Babylon, “when opportunity offered to return to the fatherland”? Not quite 100,000. What was the “smallest fraction” that “availed themselves thereof”? 42,360 (Ezra 2.64; Nehemiah 7.66), with 7,337 servants and 200 (or 245) singers (ibidem), and these were later followed by Ezra with a party of at least 1,500 (Ezra vh. 8), i. e. more than half! To be still fairer and to provide for any possible mistake in the above calculation, let us assume that those that returned were less than half; they certainly were a very considerable percentage of the Jewish population in Babylon. When we remember that the conditions in which the exiles lived were
extremely favorable, that they were kindly and considerately treated by the Babylonian and later by the Persian rulers, that their financial circumstances in prosperous Babylonia were far superior to those in desolate Palestine, when we take into consideration the perils of the journey, which took no less than four months (Ezra 7, 9), then we cannot but marvel at the unparalleled patriotism of our ancestors and we must truthfully acknowledge that it was the land whch iwas "the unifying and inspiring force in Judaism." Surely, no other nation of antiquity or of modern times has ever accomplished the task of returning to its fatherland under the same or under similar circumstances! To be sure, already then, "twenty-five hundred years ago," there were Jews in Babylon who, in the comfort and prosperity of the strange land, "forsook the Lord and forgot his holy mount" (Isaiah 65,11), who contemptuously sneered at the patriotic enthusiasts and noisily shouted: "we will be as the Gentiles, the families of the lands!" (Ezekiel 20, 32). But it was they who were the "smallest fraction," while the other Babylonian Jews "lifted up their mind to return" (Jeremiah 22, 27), and, when unable to fulfil their heart's desire, they readily and liberally assisted their more fortunate brethren (Ezra 1, 6), and showed themselves so little "spiritual" that they even donated a diadem for the rulers of the new commonwealth (Zachariah 6, 11). As for the prophets, over whom Rabbi Morgenstern and his associates seem to hold a monopoly, whose teachings and ideals we have come eo appreciate only today through Reform Judaism (compare p. 226),—the prophets were just as "narrowminded" as the "Jews" Ezra and Nehemiah and like them, expected Israel's (and mankind's) salvation to come from a "small corner of Western Asia." It was the great Isaiah who, with unparalleled patriotism, formulated the belief in the inviolability of Zion. It was Jeremiah who desperately clung to the last remains of the autonomous government under Gedaliah and, in face of supreme danger, passionately ex-