ineering, he was a figure altogether different from those writers who had theretofore ruled the Yiddish dramatic workshops. He wrote plays pulsating with life, not always Jewish, not always artistic, but always vigorous, and always entertaining. He was unfortunate in coming at a time when the star system had developed, unfortunate to be compelled to write a great deal in order to earn a livelihood, and unfortunate in being obstinately opposed to viewing Jewish life from any point except that of reminiscence, or of socialistic propaganda. But he filled the Yiddish repertoire with dramas that are ambitious in scope, excellent in character drawing, even if they are often untrue to life and unmindful of valid psychology. At a time when his powers had matured, he was too much engrossed in writing for the theatre, and too little devoted to the study of life. But with all his faults, to him the Yiddish theatre owes its largest individual debt.
With Gordin and the star system came a number of inferior men like Kobrin and Libin, who imitated his method, but who lacked his imagination, his strength in the creation of characters and dramatic situation and who sought to utilize for their own advantage the opportunity the theatre gave them for the exploitation of their feeble ideas. They too wrote primarily for the theatre, and soon they were divorced from real life when confronted by the demands of stars and managers, and they lost their grip on the situation.
But it must not be forgotten, that Gordin, Libin, Kobrin had their plays performed simultaneously with the plays of Lateiner, Shakewitz and Hurwitz; that while Mirele Efros, Zubrochene Ketten, Channele, Zubrochene Herzer, and others were being presented, Hurwitz was managing a theatre in New York, Boris Thomascheffsky was playing Lateiner shund, and even the same companies that were giving Gordin and Libin plays were also profiting at the same timee by the popular demand for shund. The Yiddish theatre was never without shund. It never was able to thor-
oughly emancipate itself from Lateiner and Hurwitz; it never had a large enough body of theatre-goers who could maks` Gordin's Gott, Mensch und Teufel as successful as Schomer's Emigranten. And even Gordin himself, during that period, wrote Die Schoene Miriam on the style or Schomer, which made the greatest success up to that time of any Yiddish play.
But, in spite of these facts, the Yiddish theatre was imbued with the feeling, owing to the arrival of Gordin and his disciples, that shund was nothing more than rot; it never deluded itself. But at the present time there seems to be a feeling that shund is, taking it all in all, not so bad, and the patriots of Gordin shake their heads when Gordin's name is mentioned, as if he had joined the mighty army of the immortals, who are neither seen nor heard.
Goldfaden was a disciple of the Haskala. The Haskala made possible a Yiddish theatre. Had Goldfaden been a master dramatist, he would have written plays in which the conflict of ideas between the new forces and the old, pious, chassidic elements would have been portrayed. Goldfaden did touch the subject, but very feebly, with ridicule, and, it must be admitted, for an audience which was not able to understand a sincere effort in that direction. Had the Yiddish theatre been a true reflection of Jewish life, it would have been able to contribute something of value to Jewish life; it would have been able to pass on, in the form of stage pictures, an appreciation of Jewish life.
The Yiddish theatre started in America under great disadvantages. Whatever was Jewish in life, aside from its religious manifestations, was busied with the radical propaganda. There were socialists and anarchists and other ists in those days; the various movements were living in the Jewish community. Men and women were devoted to the circulation of their ideas and ideals. The East Side was busy adjusting itself to life, and it projected all sorts of radical innovations. But the Yiddish theatre was silent. It was playing with Lateiner, with Hurwitz, with Schomer.